With Quebec Liberals on the ropes, liberalism in the province is at a crossroads

In the last provincial election, Quebec's Liberal Party suffered its worst defeat in its 151-year history. Even the most optimistic projections suggest the party will fare even worse when the votes are tallied on Monday.

Recent polls place Liberal support between 15 and 20 per cent, battling three other parties for second place. Before 2018, the Liberals had never received less than 30 per cent of the vote.

The party still stands a decent chance of holding onto Official Opposition status, thanks to remaining strongholds on the island of Montreal. 

But with little prospect of making inroads in majority francophone ridings, this would be cold comfort for a party that has dominated modern Quebec political history. 

While it is possible to rattle off a long list of factors that contributed to its decline — lingering memories of corruption, unpopularity of austerity governments, a political spectrum crowded by newcomers — it is perhaps simpler to say the Quebec Liberals haven't been able to keep pace with the conservative nationalism of the Coalition Avenir Québec (CAQ).

Coalition Avenir Quebec Leader François Legault reacts to supporters as he arrives at a rally on Sept. 11 in Drummondville, Que. (Jacques Boissinot/The Canadian Press)

Since Confederation, the Liberals had been the main champion of liberal values in Quebec, channeling beliefs about the importance of private property and individual rights into government policies.

Liberal governments were behind the push for a more secular education system at the dawn of the 20th century, gave women the right to vote during the Second World War and brought in a provincial charter of human rights in 1975.

A diminished party means liberal values face an uncertain future in the province. 

Not only does the CAQ look set to consolidate its hold on government, Liberals (and liberals) must contend with an ideologically diverse opposition that is trying to sweep them into the dustbin of history.

The rise of Quebec liberalism

After Confederation, there were effectively two parties in the province, the Liberals and the Conservatives. 

The Liberals represented a more moderate version of the radical anticlerical rouge party of the pre-Confederation years. It was the Conservatives, though, inheritors of the pro-Catholic Church bleu tradition, who held the upper hand for most of the late 19th century.

Buoyed by the popularity of Wilfrid Laurier, the French-Canadian Liberal prime minister, the Quebec Liberals won the 1897 election and began a nearly four decade-long hold on power.

Historians often attribute this success to the party's embrace of economic development and material progress. 

Whereas the Conservatives advocated for agricultural traditions, the Liberals encouraged industrialization by providing incentives to foreign companies to set up factories in the province.

The Liberals of Lomer Gouin and Louis-Alexandre Taschereau also sought to modernize the education system. But they were cautious not to extend to remit of the state too much; society was still considered the domain of the church.

The Liberals finally lost power in 1936 to the Union National, a new and fervently conservative party led by Maurice Duplessis. 

While in opposition, the party overhauled its platform to include the interventionist ideas advocated by the British economist John Maynard Keynes.

Since being nationalized in 1962 by Minister of Natural Resources René Lévesque, centre, and Premier Jean Lesage, left, Hydro-Québec has been regarded as a symbol of provincial pride. (Hydro-Québec)

It came to see the state as a powerful tool to further the modernization of the province and address social inequalities, chief among them being the marginal role francophones played in the Quebec business world.

The Duplessis-era came to an end in 1960, when Jean Lesage led an unruly coalition of liberals and moderate nationalists to power, kick-starting what became known as the Quiet Revolution.

Under the slogan Maîtres chez nous ("Masters in our own home"), the Lesage government undertook a dizzying array of reforms, including legal protections for unionized workers, ending the church's role in the education system and nationalizing nearly a dozen electricity companies.

Arguably, though, the crowning achievement of Quebec liberalism didn't come until 1975, when the Quebec Charter of Human Rights and Freedoms was passed unanimously by the Liberal government of Robert Bourassa.

The charter, the product of a 12-year effort, protects a wide range of political, economic and social rights. Both the Parti Québécois and the Liberals saw it as a necessary set of limits on the power of the state, which had just grown dramatically in size.

The fall of Quebec liberalism

In the 1980s, with the province facing another economic crisis, liberalism shed its statist bent. Bourassa, in his second stint as premier, privatized several state entities that had been set up during the Quiet Revolution. 

This pro-business, more managerial approach to liberalism was a central feature of the party's defence against the separatist sentiment that swelled after the failures of the Meech Lake and Charlottetown accords.

Sound economic management was contrasted with the adventure of independence from Canada. It proved a winning argument. Aside from an 18-month period, the Liberals remained in power between 2003 and 2018. 

But if neo-liberalism proved an effective strategy against sovereignty, it has failed to soothe the anxieties about identity and immigration that surfaced in the mid-2000s and have remained a fixture of Quebec politics ever since.

A revived conservative nationalist movement, led by François Legault and the CAQ, argues that liberalism exacerbates anxieties about identity by prioritizing individual and minority rights ahead of the collective rights of the francophone majority.

Quebec Premier Robert Bourassa speaks in the legislature after the failure of the Meech Lake Accord on June 22, 1990. (The Canadian Press)

This is how his government justifies using the notwithstanding clause to protect the Laicity Act — a.k.a. Bill 21, which bans many civil servants from wearing religious symbols — and his new language law (Bill 96) from charter challenges.

Notably, Legault has invoked the notwithstanding clause in not only the federal charter of rights, but the provincial one as well, signalling a clear break with Quebec's liberal tradition.

In a debate last week, the current Liberal leader, Dominique Anglade, mounted a passionate defence of her opposition to Legault's two flagship pieces of legislation, both of which are popular with voters.

"We were the only party to vote against Bill 96 and Bill 21 because of a question of values," she said.

A poll released on Tuesday suggested she lost the debate, with only six per cent of voters picking her as the winner.

Throughout its history, the Quebec Liberal Party has been able to adapt its brand of liberalism to confront whoever its main rival happened to be, be it conservative nationalists or social-democratic sovereigntists.

But now liberalism is no longer one of only two options on the menu. 

On Monday, voters in Quebec can choose between the progressive sovereigntist politics of Québec Solidaire, the PQ's mix of conservative identity politics and left-wing economic policies and the conspiracy-minded libertarianism of Eric Duhaime's Conservatives.

The future of liberal politics in Quebec depends on Anglade making a long familiar ideology stand out in a field crowded with newcomers.


Football news:

<!DOCTYPE html>
Kane on Tuchel: A wonderful man, full of ideas. Thomas in person says what he thinks
Zarema about Kuziaev's 350,000 euros a year in Le Havre: Translate it into rubles - it's not that little. It is commendable that he left
Aleksandr Mostovoy on Wendel: Two months of walking around in the middle of nowhere and then coming back and dragging the team - that's top level
Sheffield United have bought Euro U21 champion Archer from Aston Villa for £18.5million
Alexander Medvedev on SKA: Without Gazprom, there would be no Zenit titles. There is a winning wave in the city. The next victory in the Gagarin Cup will be in the spring
Smolnikov ended his career at the age of 35. He became the Russian champion three times with Zenit

3:12 Hamilton to seek veto over landfill applications amid odour issue in Stoney Creek
3:09 WRHA palliative home care on good path after failures, review recommendations: advocate
3:07 Averted disaster on Horizon flight renews scrutiny on mental health of those in cockpit
2:57 Averted disaster on Horizon Air flight renews scrutiny on mental health of those in the cockpit
2:56 Vancouver Island jewelry dealer targeted by thieves for 22nd time
2:54 French-language universities back English counterparts in criticizing tuition hike for non-Quebec students
2:51 Maggie Mac Neil makes Pan Am Games history with fifth gold medal
2:51 Georgia restaurant’s ‘bad parenting fee’ eats away at some customers
2:17 Raptors tip off Rajakovic era by spreading out offence to top T-Wolves
2:16 Schroder leads new-look Raptors to win
2:15 Dennis Schroder leads new-look Raptors to season-opening 97-94 win over Timberwolves
2:08 Arnold Schwarzenegger says he’d make ‘great president,’ but calls for ‘young blood’ in 2024
1:53 Some charges stayed against Vancouver escort
1:48 Vancouver man accused in Chinatown graffiti spree heads to court
1:43 At least 16 dead in Maine shooting, law enforcement sources say
1:43 At least 16 dead after shootings at bar, bowling alley in Lewiston, Maine
1:38 ‘LOCK DOWN’: Active shooter in Lewiston, Maine; cops investigating multiple scenes
1:38 ‘LOCK DOWN’: At least 10 dead in Maine shooting, number expected to rise
1:38 At least 16 dead in Maine shooting and dozens injured, cops say
1:30 Bank of Canada holds interest rate: What this means for British Columbians
1:30 At least 10 dead in Maine shooting and number expected to rise, law enforcement officials tell AP
1:30 At least 16 dead in Maine shooting and dozens injured, law enforcement officials tell AP
1:29 No, 1 pick Victor Wembanyama is set to debut with the San Antonio Spurs and the world is watching
1:29 No, 1 pick Victor Wembanyama debuts with the Spurs and the world is watching
1:27 Mom who killed kids in Idaho will be sent to Arizona to face murder charges
1:25 Active shooter reported in Maine, police investigating multiple scenes
1:19 King Township man charged after 3-D printed handgun, other weapons seized
1:17 Would-be hit men sentenced to 10 years for 2020 Vancouver shooting
1:16 Thousands of Las Vegas hotel workers fighting for new union contracts rally, block Strip traffic
1:16 Union workers arrested on Las Vegas Strip for blocking traffic as thousands rally
1:15 Calgary’s housing crisis: Those left behind share their stories
1:11 Imprisoned ‘apostle’ of Mexican megachurch La Luz del Mundo charged with federal child pornography
1:10 Police to detonate suspicious package ‘shortly’ in city’s north end
1:07 FIQ healthcare union votes to strike Nov. 8-9
1:07 St. Lawrence Seaway strike concerns politicians, stakeholders in Hamilton and Niagara
1:04 U.S. autoworkers reach deal with Ford, breakthrough toward ending strikes
1:02 Calgary police chief unaware honour guard attended controversial prayer breakfast, but ‘not surprised’
1:00 Laura Jones: Regulation should be about improving our quality of life while minimizing red tape
0:58 Montreal hosting government, community groups, law enforcement in gun violence forum
0:50 Two arrested in Kelowna homicide investigation: RCMP
0:49 Mom convicted of killing kids in Idaho will be sent to Arizona to face murder conspiracy charges
0:47 B.C. residents split on future of provincial carbon tax: poll
0:34 Do you know Slim? B.C. RCMP seek person of interest in fatal Sparwood shooting
0:32 B.C. mother-daughter jewelry designing team featured in Rolls-Royce book
0:30 The U.S. House has a speaker. What does that mean for Israel, Ukraine aid?
0:22 Héma-Québec adding new virtual experience to boost number of blood donors
0:22 Letters to the Editor, Oct. 26, 2023
0:19 What’s trending this Halloween in the Okanagan
0:16 Teens charged with retired cop’s murder accused of flipping off his kin in court
0:13 Dusty Baker tells newspaper he is retiring as manager of Houston Astros
0:09 UAW, Ford reach tentative deal to end weeks-long strike: sources
0:09 Volunteers harvest thousands of eggs as salmon return to South Surrey river
0:03 LILLEY: Canada’s Jewish community feels like it is under assault
0:02 Ex-NFL player Sergio Brown, charged with killing mother, denied release
23:56 $15 million class-action lawsuit brought against York University and student union
23:55 Ex-NBA star Dwight Howard denies sexual assault suit filed by Georgia man
23:54 Quebec taxpayers shouldn't completely bail out Montreal-area transit companies: Guilbault
23:54 Lethbridge training exercise sees emergency responders practice responding to large crowds
23:51 Driver in Malibu crash that killed 4 college students charged with murder
23:47 Canada to send additional humanitarian aid to Nagorno-Karabakh, Gaza, West Bank and Israel
23:45 Hurricane Otis unleashes massive flooding in Acapulco, triggers landslides
23:44 MANDEL: Nygard tells court no one could be locked inside his bedroom suite
23:41 North Vancouver architecture team designs Indigenous-inspired buildings that blend with nature
23:41 Airports see surge in asylum claims after border, visa requirement changes
23:37 Vaughn Palmer: David Eby makes no apologies for calling for halt to interest rate hikes
23:35 Housing crisis bears down on some of Calgary’s most vulnerable
23:35 'I will never look at myself as a murderer,' says man convicted of St-Laurent murder
23:34 Mac Neil leads another big day in the pool for Canada at Pan Am Games
23:27 Hydro-Quebec rates ‘never’ to increase above 3 per cent, premier promises
23:27 Pro-Palestinian protesters call for immediate ceasefire in Gaza at rally in Ottawa
23:26 TransLink faces $4.7 billion financial void by 2033 without funding change
23:21 Guy Favreau shelter could be granted winter reprieve, says city
23:15 Deer scatters diners after charging into crowded Wisconsin restaurant
23:09 Emergency homeless shelter at The Gathering Place: New Beginnings continues operations
23:02 Alberta premier promises firm exit number before referendum on CPP
23:01 Professor who called Hamas slaughter ‘exhilarating’ on leave
23:01 B.C. and Washington State agree to address Nooksack River flooding, set no timeline or obligations
22:59 Gregoire Trudeau ‘re-partnered’ months before separation announced: Report
22:58 Maple Leaf notes: Ontario Sports Hall of an honour for Shanahan and more video victories
22:57 Canadian connection: Timberwolves’ Miller learning NBA ropes from Alexander-Walker
22:57 Okanagan MLA Ben Stewart not seeking re-election in 2024
22:56 Mac Neil becomes Canada’s most decorated Pan Am Games athlete with fifth gold medal
22:55 Saskatoon green cart material to be processed in-house, temporarily lowering costs
22:51 A Montrealer by choice, Restaurant Gus chef shows what out-of-province students can contribute
22:50 Hate crimes against Jews and Muslims on the rise since Hamas attack
22:47 Federal officials say plan for water cuts from 3 Western states is enough to protect Colorado River
22:47 Ex-NFL player Sergio Brown, charged with killing mother, has been denied release
22:44 Seaway strike puts Saskatchewan’s international reputation at risk, producers say
22:36 Behind the concerns and complex feelings some Indigenous audiences have about Killers of the Flower Moon
22:34 Michigan State hearing officer rules Mel Tucker sexually harassed Brenda Tracy, AP source says
22:32 CPKC lowers earnings expectations due to ‘economic headwinds,’ port workers strike
22:31 ‘Fantastic’ pet food drive helps struggling military veterans in Calgary
22:24 Auto theft probe, Project Stallion, trots 228 accused before courts
22:19 Sault Ste. Marie, Ont., killer had a history of intimate partner violence, police say
22:09 Record number of visitors to food banks in Canada renews calls for greater support in Manitoba
22:08 $4.7 billion funding gap could result in major TransLink service cuts: Report
22:02 Rising cost of living putting unprecedented pressure on Canadian food banks
21:58 Turbocharged Otis caught forecasters and Mexico off-guard. Scientists aren’t sure why
21:58 Chretien reflects on 30th anniversary of election win, says House has become 'dull as hell'
21:57 Manslaughter charges arise from Saskatoon May suspicious death