The Population Decline Paranoia

For two centuries, overpopulation has haunted the imagination of the modern world. According to Thomas Malthus, writing in 1798, human population growth would always surpass agricultural production, meaning “gigantic inevitable famine” would “with one mighty blow level the population with the food of the world.”
Later, eugenicists like Margaret Sanger in the 1920s fretted over the wrong people reproducing too much, creating what she called “human weeds,” a “dead weight of human waste” to inherit the earth. In 1968, Paul Ehrlich predicted that in the 1970s, “hundreds of millions of people are going to starve to death” because of the “population bomb.” These days, environmentalists worry that too many people will overload the natural world’s resources and destroy the planet with excessive consumption and pollution, leading to catastrophic global warming.
A strain of anti-humanism has always run through population paranoia, a notion that human beings are a problem rather than a resource. This is exactly what the late Prime Minister Meles Zenawi argued. Regarding this, if my memory is serving correctly, once he said that the newly born are coming in to the world not only with the mouth to eat, but also with two hands to work.
But as Jonathan Last, a senior writer for the Weekly Standard documents in his new book entitled “What to Expect When No One’s Expecting”, it is not overpopulation that threatens the well-being of the human race, it is under-population. As he writes, throughout recorded human history, declining populations have always been followed by very bad things. Particularly for our modern, high-tech, capitalist world of consumers who buy, entrepreneurs who create wealth and jobs, and workers whose taxes fund social welfare entitlements, people are an even more critical resource.
Jonathan Last in his book provides a reader-friendly but thorough analysis of the demographic crisis afflicting the West and the very bad things that will follow population decline. The facts of population decline are dramatic. Women must average a Total Fertility Rate (TFR) of 2.1 children apiece for populations to remain stable. But across the developed world, and increasingly everywhere else, except few countries including Ethiopia, fertility is quickly declining below this number. All developed countries are already below the 2.1 line and the rates of decline among developing countries are, in most cases, even steeper than in the developed ones.
Japan and Italy, for example, have a 1.4 TFR, a mathematical tipping point at which the population will decline by 50 percent in 45 years. As for the rest of Europe, by 2050 only three countries in the EU, which today has an average rate of 1.5 TFR, will not be experiencing population declines. Those countries are France, Luxembourg, and Ireland.
Immigration from developing countries will not provide a long-term solution, as fertility rates are declining there as well. The average fertility rate for Latin America was six children per woman in the 1960s; by 2005, it had dropped to 2.5. At that rate of decline, within a few decades, Latin American countries will likely have a fertility rate lower than that of the United States.
According to Jonathan Last, the most general cause of population decline is modernity itself. Birth-rates started declining in the nineteenth century when industrialization and technological advances began to accelerate. Better nutrition, sanitation, and health care, for example, have reduced infant mortality in America from about 300 babies dying out of 1,000 live births in 1850, to about six today. More babies surviving lessened the need for multiple pregnancies, which in turn reduced family size.
During the Industrial Revolution, migration to cities made children less useful than they were on farms and more expensive. Easier divorce, reliable birth control, cohabitation replacing marriage, and women entering the workforce in greater numbers since 1990, about 70 percent of women have been working at any given time, have all contributed to the decline in marriage and the diminishing centrality of children in people’s lives. These forces have created disincentives to reproduction, not the least being the $1.1 million price tag for rearing and educating a child today.
Two larger cultural trends have reinforced the effects of technological developments and industrialization. As Last points out, fertility rates among the educated classes began falling in the middle of the eighteenth century, which was about the same time as the rise of capitalism. The pursuit of individual initiative and self-interest contributed to the erosion of community and family. Economic advancement requires mobility and fewer obligations. Constraints hamper self-improvement and risk-taking, after all. Having children, perhaps the greatest constraint of all, became less and less a factor in people’s calculations of their self-interests. Something else would be required to get people to procreate.
That imperative to reproduce used to be grounded in religion, but during the eighteenth century, secularization began to loosen the hold that religious practice, actually going to church rather than just self-identifying by sect, used to have on people’s behaviour. The effect of religious practice on fertility is obvious from statistics. Indeed, the effects of religion on fertility can be so powerful that even if people are not the churchgoing type themselves, they will be affected if their parents are.
The dire economic and social effect of plummeting birth-rates reminds that marriage and childbirth are not just private lifestyle choices. A country with fewer children becomes, on average, increasingly older. Cities and towns begin to empty, while the cost of caring for retirees and elderly sick people skyrockets. Old people spend less and invest less, shrinking capital pools for the new businesses that create new jobs. Entrepreneurs do not come from among the aged. Countries with a higher median age have a lower percentage of entrepreneurs.
Most important, a shrinking labour force means fewer workers contributing the payroll taxes that finance old-age care. According to the latest ILO data, the Social Security program is already beginning to be impacted by the decline in the worker-to-retiree ratio.
Finally, foreign policy will increasingly be impacted by the global decline in fertility. Those who fear China as a future superpower threat to their interests should remember that by 2050, China’s population will be declining by 20 million every five years, and one out of four people will be over the age of 65. China’s public pension system covers only 365 million people and is unfunded by 150 percent of GDP. Jonathan Last in his book argues that what we need to prepare for is not a shooting war with an expansionist China, but a declining superpower with a rapidly contracting economic base and an unstable political structure. It’s not clear which scenario is more worrisome.
Solving such a complex problem as declining fertility is not going to be easy. As with many social problems, government intervention isn’t very successful. Bonus payments to expectant mothers, paid paternity leave, public holidays, “Motherhood Medals,” and tax incentives and subsidies have barely moved the needle in Russia, Japan, and Singapore. People cannot be bribed into making babies.
The best governments can do is help people have the children they do want. A college degree doesn’t prepare people for specific jobs, but rather gives employers an idea of their intelligence and work habits, something that can be done more cheaply and efficiently. Making child-friendly housing more affordable, letting workers telecommute to lessen the career-costs of having children, welcoming more fecund immigrants, and ending the hostility to religion and the faithful, “if for no other reason than they’re the ones who create most of the future taxpayers,” are some of Jonathan Last’s solutions. Unfortunately, they are as unlikely as they are sensible.


Football news:

<!DOCTYPE html>
Kane on Tuchel: A wonderful man, full of ideas. Thomas in person says what he thinks
Zarema about Kuziaev's 350,000 euros a year in Le Havre: Translate it into rubles - it's not that little. It is commendable that he left
Aleksandr Mostovoy on Wendel: Two months of walking around in the middle of nowhere and then coming back and dragging the team - that's top level
Sheffield United have bought Euro U21 champion Archer from Aston Villa for £18.5million
Alexander Medvedev on SKA: Without Gazprom, there would be no Zenit titles. There is a winning wave in the city. The next victory in the Gagarin Cup will be in the spring
Smolnikov ended his career at the age of 35. He became the Russian champion three times with Zenit

12:28 REQUEST FOR EXPRESSION OF INTEREST (EOI)
7:47 Looking for Well-Qualified and Experienced House Manager (Residence Manager)
12:18 Ethiopian Gudaf shattered World 5000m record
12:15 Lending a helping hand
9:22 LEADING OR FOLLOWING?
9:18 Total Energies inaugurates polished up gas station along Bole Rd
9:16 Momentum grows to solve the world’s plastic waste problem
13:42 Religious leaders can help bring about world peace – opinion
11:39 American Silver and China’s Money Supply In The Early Globalization
13:54 Fifty eight exporters to face the long arm of the law
13:53 500 Billion birr required for metropolitan growth, City Road Authority signals
14:01 Abiy Ahmed’s Goverment declares ‘state of emergency’ over Amhara violence
16:22 Clashes Between Ethiopian Army, Rebels Disrupt Internal Flights
14:26 Negotiated Settlement is the Only Way to Avert a Civil War
13:54 Mass Movement Against Abiy Ahmed Government Is Rising In Ethiopia’s Amhara Region
5:00 Japan-Ethiopia Relations: Strengthening long history of Friendship
16:19 Ethiopian Laureate Melaku Worede, renowned conservationist and agronomist, dies at 87
12:45 Ethiopian-Americans attended a Town Hall meeting in Silver Spring, MD
6:25 Do Not Let an Extremist Amhara Wing Hijack the Fanno Movement
7:41 RESISTANCE FOR BETTER FUTURE
14:19 Introducing the Award-winning TECNO CAMON 20 Series: The Perfect Choice for All Your Smartphone Needs
12:58 MULTIGATE – The First Pan-African Financial Service to Become Swift Partner
12:58 ATI Launched Food Security and Agriculture Rehabilitation Measures in Conflict-Affected Regions of Ethiopia (FARM) Project
12:56 SITA and Indicio announce a co-innovation agreement to accelerate the development of digital identities
12:46 Ethiopian Airlines: Africa’s Only Profitable Carrier Still Faces Real Challenges
12:20 Meet Ethiopia’s richest man, Al-Amoudi, worth $5.4 billion
11:07 1,000 school students gear up for high-demand jobs with support from Coca-Cola Beverages Africa
9:49 New World Bank President to visit Ethiopia
12:37 Scrambling for Front Seats as the Ship Sinks
13:15 CCBA-Ethiopia Graduated 50 Hearing-impaired Youth & Women in Crafts
4:54 Unprecedented Economic Data Fabrication Threatens the Survival of Ethiopia
13:17 It is time to rebuild passenger confidence in checked baggage
12:08 CANEX AND AFRIFF LAUNCH ‘SCRIPT TO SCREEN’ FOR AFRICAN FILMMAKERS
11:23 Populist Politics and Globalization
9:29 City council issues a big No!
16:12 Time is on Fano’s Side !
16:05 The Horn of Africa States Grains and Food Production
14:00 The Horn of Africa States Realism the Best Weapon Between Negativity and Positivity
8:59 5 Best Binary Options Brokers in the World
8:38 CRITICAL QUERIES ARE NECESSARY
8:35 Sudan’s Humanitarian Crisis
11:57 Health Ministry receives 1.2 million Euros in medical equipment support
7:54 Melbet Ethiopia: ስለዚህ ቡክ ሰሪ ማወቅ ያለብዎ ነገር?
16:42 Abiy Ahmed: A national Disgrace and an International Embarrassment
14:29 Abiy Ahmed: The Icarus of Ethiopia
12:42 International referee Lidya Tafesse hang-up her whistle
10:44 Ethiopia’s Out- of-Control Economy !
9:28 Gudaf spearhead astonishing trio in Spain-Nerja
8:41 Lucy faces Chad in first round Olympic qualification face-off
22:56 Ethiopia: Crushing Freedom Creating Fear
16:38 The Horn of Africa States Development Diplomacy in the Integration Process
8:50 ESL fuels strategy to drive its logistics ambitions
8:49 Auditor General places parliament’s action in question!
8:48 ESL ushers new dawn with ‘Ultramax bulk carriers’
23:13 The Ethiopian Airlines: An Epitome of Oromummaa’s Predatory Greed and Gangsterism
10:39 THE NEW FRONTIER OF ANTISEMITISM: Racial Discourse and Oromo Extremism in Ethiopia
7:08 Ethiopia’s Request to Join BRICS is a Sign of Desperation, Not of Strategy
14:08 The Horn of Africa States Entrepreneurship Should be Driving the Region
12:43 Ethiopia has made an official request to join the BRICS bloc of emerging economies
22:20 U.S. Lifts Human Rights Violation Designation on Ethiopia despite evidence of ongoing abuses
12:15 The Horn of Africa States Beyond the Last Century Histories
9:03 Tender Extension Notice
8:57 CONSOLIDATING THE HORN
18:11 Who is Addis Ababa for?
9:37 NMC Real Estate hits the ground running
9:35 Wild Coffee Ethiopia widens horizon to Kenya
8:57 “Be vigilant!” Authority warns market funders
5:49 The chairwoman of Ethiopia’s National Election Commission (NEBE), Birtukan Mideksan resigns
14:43 The Horn of Africa States The Politics and Economics of Water Issues
22:13 The International Community Must Express Ourtrage Now: Torture of Amhara must stop
14:11 Ethiopia: More turbulence ahead for Ethiopian Airlines
9:15 The Horn of Africa States A Regional Perspective
16:07 Standardized Entrepreneurship Training Manual and Business Development Service (BDS) Guideline Development
16:06 Comprehensive Employability and Soft Skill Training Curriculum + Guideline Development
11:51 Multi-Power Hegemonic Rivalry in the Horn of Africa: Geopolitical Implications and Potential Consequences for the Regional States
5:47 Let the World Know About Ethiopian Orthodox and Why They Were Killed by ISIS and Now Being Hunted by Oromummaa
14:26 The Horn of Africa States: A Geopolitical Case (Part II)
14:25 Radisson announces seven new hotels in Africa for the first half of 2023
14:24 UN special representative highlights humanitarian situation on visit to Somalia
14:23 USAID launches a $12 Million Health Resilience Project
14:13 The Reason Behind Ato Girma Wake’s Termination
11:49 Ethiopia still nursing 28.7 billion USD in conflict wounds, study shows
11:46 Central bank deploys ‘regulatory sandbox’ to expand financial sector
11:45 Mortgage financier, Goh Betoch, lobbies for a housing fund
15:09 The Horn of Africa States Rebranding of IGAD as “HAS” (Part II)
5:30 Ethiopian Airlines earnings jump 20% in 2022/2023 fiscal year
12:00 The Horn of Africa States Rebranding “IGAD” as “HAS”
8:28 Calls for Request for Proposal (RFP):
11:03 The Horn of Africa States De-Federalization – A Possibility?
18:56 A Respected Chairman Fired by Abiy Ahmed and Replaced By Air Force Commander for Political Purpose
13:14 Hassan, Bol and Duplantis on show as strong fields get set for Hengelo
13:08 Asmara Marathon to be held on 11 June
13:07 Kiplimo and Aregawi in 5000m head-to-head
8:33 Huawei stresses its commitment to inclusive and sustainable digital transformation at the Africa CEO Forum 2023
8:25 How a designer’s chairs made it onto the set of a Hollywood blockbuster
8:04 Election board declines new request for TPLF as regional party
22:36 Resolving the Wolkait Debate Peacefully and Justly Matters for All Ethiopians
19:41 Eritrea has rejoined the East African bloc, the Inter-Governmental Authority on Development (IGAD)
12:11 Invitation to Bid SUPPLY OF EXERCISE BOOKS
11:43 INVITATION TO OPEN TENDER