Will this time be different? Iranian women are ‘seeking a revolutionary change’

AP — A young woman climbs to the top of a car in the middle of Mashhad, a conservative Iranian city famed for its Islamic shrines. She takes off her headscarf and starts chanting, “Death to the dictator!” Protesters nearby join in and cars honk in support.

For many Iranian women, it’s an image that would have been unthinkable just a decade ago, said Fatemeh Shams, who grew up in Mashhad.

“When you see Mashhad women coming to the streets and burning their veils publicly, this is really a revolutionary change. Iranian women are putting an end to a veiled society and the compulsory veil,” she said.

Iran has seen multiple eruptions of protests over the past years, many of them fueled by anger over economic difficulties. But the new wave is showing fury against something at the heart of the identity of Iran’s cleric-led state: the compulsory veil.

Iran’s Islamic Republic requires women to cover up in public, including wearing a “hijab” or headscarf that is supposed to completely hide the hair. Many Iranian women, especially in major cities, have long played cat-and-mouse with authorities, with younger generations wearing loose scarves and outfits that push the boundaries of conservative dress.

Get The Times of Israel's Daily Edition by email and never miss our top stories

By signing up, you agree to the terms

It can end in tragedy. A 22-year-old woman, Mahsa Amini, was arrested by the so-called morality police for allegedly violating the dress code in the capital Tehran, and died after she was taken into custody.

In a photo taken by an individual not employed by the Associated Press and obtained by the AP outside Iran, a police motorcycle burns during a protest over the death of a young woman who had been detained for violating the country’s conservative dress code, in downtown Tehran, Iran. (AP Photo)

Her death has sparked nearly two weeks of widespread unrest that has reached across Iran’s provinces and brought students, middle-class professionals and working-class men and women into the streets.

Iranian state TV has suggested that at least 41 protesters and police have been killed. Human rights groups say the death toll is at least 75.

A young woman in Tehran, who said she has continually participated in the past week’s protests in the capital city, said the violent response of security forces had largely reduced the size of demonstrations.

“People still are coming to the streets to find one meter of space to shout their rage but they are immediately and violently chased, beaten and taken into custody, so they try to mobilize in four- to five-person groups and once they find an opportunity they run together and start to demonstrate,” she said, speaking on condition of anonymity.

“The most important protest they (Iranian women) are doing right now is taking off their scarves and burning them,” she added. “This is a women’s movement first of all, and men are supporting them in the backline.”

A protester holds a portrait of Mahsa Amini during a demonstration in support of Amini, a young Iranian woman who died after being arrested in Tehran by the Islamic Republic’s morality police, on Istiklal avenue in Istanbul on September 20, 2022. (Ozan KOSE / AFP)

A writer and rights activist since her student days at Tehran University, Shams participated in the mass anti-government protests of 2009 before having to flee Iran.

But this time is different, she said.

Waves of violent repression against protests in the past 13 years “have disillusioned the traditional classes of society” that once were the backbone of the Islamic Republic, said Shams, who now lives in the United States.

The fact that there have been protests in conservative cities like Mashhad or Qom — the historic center of Iran’s clergy — is unprecedented, she said.

“Every morning I wake up and I think, is this actually happening? Women making bonfires with veils?”

Women of Iran are leading a movement against religious dictatorship.

We are not fighting against a small piece of cloth.

Forced hijab is one of the most visible symbol of oppression.

We want separation from religion and politics in the Middle East.#MahsaAmini #مهسا_امینی pic.twitter.com/LqdGw6FPK8

— Masih Alinejad ????️ (@AlinejadMasih) September 26, 2022

Modern Iranian history has been full of unexpected twists and turns.

Iranian women who grew up before the overthrow of the monarchy in 1979 remember a country where women were largely free to choose how they dressed.

People of all stripes, from leftists to religious hardliners, participated in the revolution that toppled the shah. But in the end, it was Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini and his followers who ended up seizing power and creating a Shiite cleric-led Islamic state.

The scenes in Iran are astonishing. How far will these protests go?
pic.twitter.com/AJeHB0yyYB

— Frida Ghitis (@FridaGhitis) September 20, 2022

On March 7, 1979, Khomeini announced that all women must wear hijab. The very next day — International Women’s Day — tens of thousands of unveiled women marched in protest.

“It was really the first counter-revolutionary movement,” said Susan Maybud, who participated in those marches and was then working as a news assistant with the foreign press. “It wasn’t just about the hijab, because we knew what was next, taking away women’s rights.” She didn’t even own a hijab at the time, she recalled.

“What you’re seeing today is not something that just happened. There’s been a long history of women protesting and defying authority” in Iran.

Women walk in a park in Iran’s capital Tehran, September 27, 2022. (Photo by AFP)

The hijab has been “the lightning rod of opposition,” explained Roham Alvandi, an Iranian historian and associate professor at the London School of Economics and Political Science.

“It represents the ability of the Islamic Republic to reach down and control the most private and intimate aspects of Iranians’ lives,” he said.

A century or more ago, strict veiling was largely limited to Iran’s upper classes. Most women were in rural areas and worked, “so hijab wasn’t exactly possible” for them, said Esha Momeni, an Iranian activist and scholar affiliated with UCLA’s Gender Studies Department.

Many women wore a “roosari” or casual headscarf that was “part of traditional clothing rather than having a very religious meaning to it.”

Iranian women take part during the celebrations to mark the 2,500 anniversary of the founding of the Persian Empire, at Persepolis Iran, October 13, 1971. (Horst Faas/AP)

Throughout the late 19th century, women were front-and-center in street protests, she said. In Iran’s first democratic uprising of 1905, many towns and cities formed local women’s rights committees.

This was followed by a period of top-down secularizing reforms under the military officer-turned-king Reza Shah, who banned the wearing of the veil in public in the 1930s.

During the Islamic Revolution, women’s hijab became an important political symbol of the country “entering this new Islamic era,” Momeni said. Growing up in Tehran, she remembers “living between two worlds” where family and friends didn’t wear the veil at private gatherings but feared harassment or arrest by police or pro-government militias in public.

In 2008, Momeni was arrested and kept in solitary confinement for a month at Tehran’s notorious Evin Prison, after working on a documentary about women activists and the 1 Million Signatures Campaign that aimed to reform discriminatory laws against women. She was later released and joined the 2009 “Green Movement” protests.

In this photo taken by an individual not employed by the Associated Press and obtained by the AP outside Iran, protesters chant slogans during a protest over the death of a woman who was detained by the morality police, in downtown Tehran, Iran, September 21, 2022. (AP)

Like Shams, she sees today’s wave of protests as shaking the foundations of the Islamic Republic.

“People are done with the hope of internal reform. People not wanting hijab is a sign of them wanting the system to change fundamentally,” Momeni said.

The 2009 protests were led by Iran’s “reformist” movement which called for a gradual opening-up of Iranian society. But none of Iran’s political parties — even the most progressive, reformist-led ones — supported abolishing the compulsory veil.

Shams, who grew up in relatively religious family and sometimes wore hijab, recounted how during the 2009 protests, she renounced the headscarf publicly. She found herself under attack by pro-government media, but also shunned by figures in the reform movement — and by her then-husband’s family.

“The major reason for our divorce was compulsory hijab,” she said.

A pro-government demonstrator holds a poster of the late Iranian revolutionary founder Ayatollah Khomeini while attending a rally after the Friday prayers to condemn recent anti-government protests over the death of a young woman in police custody, in Tehran, Iran, Sept. 23, 2022. (Vahid Salemi/AP)

As Iran has been besieged by US sanctions and several waves of protests fueled by economic grievances, the leadership has grown insular and uncompromising.
In the 2021 presidential election, all serious contenders were disqualified to allow Ebrahim Raisi, a protégé of Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei, to take the presidency despite record low voter turnout.

The death of Mahsa Amini, who hailed from a relatively impoverished Kurdish area, has galvanized anger over forms of ethnic and social — as well as gender — discrimination, Shams said.

From Tehran’s universities to far-flung Kurdish towns, men and women protesters have chanted, “Whoever kills our sister, we will kill them.”

Shams says Iran’s rulers have backed themselves into a corner, where they fear yielding on the veil could endanger the 44-year-old Islamic Republic.

“There is no way back, at this point. If the Islamic Republic wants to stay in power, they have to abolish compulsory veiling, but in order to do that they have to transform their political ideology,” she said. “And the Islamic government is not ready for that change.”

Times of Israel staff contributed to this report.


Football news:

<!DOCTYPE html>
Kane on Tuchel: A wonderful man, full of ideas. Thomas in person says what he thinks
Zarema about Kuziaev's 350,000 euros a year in Le Havre: Translate it into rubles - it's not that little. It is commendable that he left
Aleksandr Mostovoy on Wendel: Two months of walking around in the middle of nowhere and then coming back and dragging the team - that's top level
Sheffield United have bought Euro U21 champion Archer from Aston Villa for £18.5million
Alexander Medvedev on SKA: Without Gazprom, there would be no Zenit titles. There is a winning wave in the city. The next victory in the Gagarin Cup will be in the spring
Smolnikov ended his career at the age of 35. He became the Russian champion three times with Zenit

3:16 At least 16 killed, dozens injured in mass shooting in Maine
2:46 French soccer league suspends player for sharing antisemitic social media post
1:59 Biden and PM discuss freeing hostages held by Hamas, letting foreigners out of Gaza
1:35 ‘Glory to our martyrs’ protected onto building at George Washington University
1:35 ‘Glory to our martyrs’ projected onto building at George Washington University
1:11 Ministry issues ‘protocol for treatment’ of freed captives after press event slammed
0:51 Biden: There’s no going back to pre-war status quo, there must be vision of 2 states
23:23 Cooper Union Jewish students attacked by pro-Palestinian student group
23:23 WATCH: Cooper Union Jewish students attacked by pro-Palestinian student group
22:14 Settlers rampage through Palestinian olive grove, harass activists in West Bank
22:12 Nineteen days since the massacre, Israel has achieved nothing. It’s time to go in
22:10 Israeli and Jewish-owned restaurants in the US are raising money for Hamas victims
22:09 The war with Hamas could threaten Israel’s imports
21:27 6 lightly hurt following rocket barrage from Gaza toward central, southern Israel
21:27 6 lightly hurt in rocket barrage from Gaza toward central, southern Israel
21:15 Irish Wix employee fired for inflammatory posts about Israel-Hamas war
20:51 UN chief doubles down on Hamas remarks, decries ‘misrepresentations’
20:50 Israeli Opera soloists sing ‘Bring Him Home,’ for Gaza captives
20:09 Netanyahu: Following war, everyone will have to answer for failures, ‘including me’
20:09 Netanyahu: After the war, everyone will have to answer for failures, ‘including me’
20:05 Ending weeks of gridlock, Republicans elect Trump ally Mike Johnson as House speaker
19:17 Israel said to delay Gaza invasion to allow US to bolster air defenses in region
19:09 500 Hamas, PIJ terrorists trained for October 7 attack in Iran last month – report
19:04 Danny Vovk, 45: ZAKA diver fended off 20 terrorists before death
18:57 Palestinian arrested in Brussels for talk about planning a suicide bombing
18:50 Noam Slotki, 31, Yishay Slotki, 24: Brothers fought and died together
18:46 Barkat slams Treasury, presents rival emergency aid plan for war-affected businesses
18:41 Sgt. Yarin Peled, 20: Medic who scrawled last request facing death
18:39 Serving up love: Israelis see war as catalyst to matchmake
18:35 Ben Mizrachi, 22: Former IDF medic killed while helping others
17:52 Senate panel okays Biden’s pick for Israel envoy, with final vote likely next week
17:37 NYPD data shows spike in antisemitic attacks during Israel-Hamas war
17:28 Germany seeks to bar antisemites from gaining citizenship amid spike in incidents
17:25 4 עקרונות מפתח לחינוך בעת מלחמה
16:59 Arab Israeli actress freed to house arrest amid alleged Hamas support
15:18 משרד הבריאות: חטופים שישוחררו יטופלו במתחם נפרד בבית החולים
15:18 חטופים שישוחררו יטופלו במתחם נפרד: "לתעד עדויות לפשעי מלחמה"
15:18 מתחם נפרד לטיפול בחטופים הבאים שישוחררו: "לתעד פשעי מלחמה"
15:08 Jordan queen skeptical Israeli children were beheaded by Hamas during onslaught
15:05 Hostage negotiators say pilloried Israeli envoy a nonfactor in talks
14:49 Former Trump lawyer Michael Cohen resumes testimony in business fraud lawsuit
14:48 Rights group reports over 100 assaults by settlers on Palestinians since war’s start
13:36 בגלל מחסור במאבטחים: בתי החולים הונחו לגבש כיתות כוננות
13:05 "הקליעים חוררו את הציורים": האמנית זיוה ילין הצילה את עבודותיה מקיבוץ בארי
12:55 "החזרה לשגרה של הילדים האלה היא המשימה הגדולה שלנו כמבוגרים"
12:24 יהיה בסדר? סמוטריץ', תקשיב לרופאים | טור
10:37 השר עמיחי אליהו: "לסגור את התאגיד, הוא מחליש את הרוח"
8:14 מאמר בכתב עת רפואי: "ישראל תקפה את בית החולים בעזה, הכיבוש אשם"
10:18 בואו נדבר על ביטחון: האם ללמוד בבית ספר או בזום?
8:52 אנשי החינוך, אתם המנהיגים האמיתיים שלנו
11:35 Gaza group threatens renewal of border clashes, blaming ‘desecration’ of Temple Mount
11:21 Daily Briefing Oct. 1: How ‘Jewish space missiles’ will soon protect Germany’s skies
10:25 This artist sees romantic realism at the beach, in a hammock and on the street
10:25 Artist sees romantic realism at the beach, in a hammock and on the street
10:15 Dingy carrying foreign nationals’ ID papers, but no people, washes up in Netanya
9:43 סרטן שד בישראל: פחות נשים מאובחנות, יותר נשים מאובחנות בשלב מוקדם
8:53 אישה אושפזה במצב קשה ברמב"ם עקב שתיית אלכוהול מזויף
8:37 Suicide bomber detonates device in Turkish capital, wounding 2 police officers
8:33 Pro-Russia former premier leads leftist party to victory in Slovakia elections
8:15 After 75 years, IDF identifies remains of soldier killed in War of Independence
7:58 After shots fired, kibbutz residents enter nearby Palestinian village
7:32 גילי ניצלה ממפרצת נדירה, המנתח: "כזה דבר לא ראיתי מעולם"
7:24 Explosion heard in Turkish capital, media report
5:59 Palestinian-Italian student, held by Israel for a month, faces court hearing
5:00 מה הקשר בין אהוד אולמרט לרוברט דה נירו?
4:05 כל מה שרצית לדעת על הנקה: התנוחה, התדירות והקשיים | המדריך המלא
3:56 כוננות שפעת: עלייה באשפוזי ילדים בחצי הכדור הדרומי
3:49 Yom Kippur War a needed ‘slap in the face,’ says vet who helped reverse battle’s tide
2:59 NJ megamall to offer gender-segregated swimming on Sukkot for Orthodox clientele
2:11 Is Poland’s government shooting itself in the foot with its cooling stance on Ukraine?
1:29 Threat of shutdown ends as Congress passes temporary funding plan, sends it to Biden
1:18 Jimmy Carter admirers across generations celebrate former president’s 99th birthday
0:58 IDF reportedly strikes Iranian weapons shipment near Damascus
0:13 Haredi MK: Yom Kippur scuffles prove anti-gov’t protesters waging ‘religious war’
22:34 90% of ethnic Armenians flee Karabakh enclave overrun by Azerbaijan army
22:13 Democrat pulls fire alarm in House building amid vote on bill to prevent shutdown
21:35 Last-gasp House drama moves US away from government shutdown
21:20 Dozens arrested in Iran in demonstration commemorating ‘Bloody Friday’ anniversary
20:45 Five dead, five hurt in Illinois collision that leaked toxic substance
20:32 Eritrean man stabbed to death in Netanya, in latest brawl between migrants
20:29 Female prison guards, officials to be questioned over alleged sex scandal
19:32 New York City begins to dry out after record rainfall, intense flooding
19:31 ‘You won’t divide us’: Protesters against overhaul rally for a 39th weekend
18:59 Azerbaijan says serviceman killed by sniper, Armenia denies incident
18:43 Head of think tank behind overhaul push says it was rushed, poorly prepared
18:24 Arab man shot and killed in north, community’s 11th murder this week
16:08 Man stabbed to death in Jerusalem in apparent criminal incident
16:05 Women of the Senate remember Dianne Feinstein as tireless fighter, true friend
15:46 Chicago Sukkot festival reflects on complex history between city’s Blacks and Jews
14:07 Netanyahus set to vacation again at Golan Heights hotel, despite local opposition
13:54 A New York exhibit explores the etrog’s journey around the Jewish world
13:54 Thick-skinned world traveler: NYC exhibit explores the life and times of the etrog
11:04 Musk wades into German political debate over migrant ‘invasion’
10:17 יותר מ-100 אלף איש ברחו לארמניה: "האזרים ישחטו את כולם"
10:15 Thousands expected at 39th week of anti-overhaul demonstrations
10:15 Tens of thousands expected at 39th week of anti-overhaul demonstrations
9:33 Putin marks anniversary of annexation of Ukrainian regions as drones attack
8:41 Jerusalem Latin Patriarch among 21 new cardinals anointed by Pope
6:42 US on brink on government shutdown, funding chaos
5:37 US pro-Palestinian group lauds Second Intifada that ‘renewed flame of resistance’