Bureaucrats: Uncivil strife

A January 12 letter from the Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT) of the Union ministry of home affairs (MHA) to the states has the latter up in umbrage. The letter called for responses by January 25 to a proposal for changes in sharing of bureaucrats from the All India Services (AIS), which includes the Indian Administrative Service (IAS), Indian Police Service (IPS) and Indian Forest Service (IFoS).

The DoPT letter comes in the wake of a perceived shortage of AIS officers in Union ministries. It says the states “are not sponsoring an adequate number of officers for central deputation”, leading to a shortage in meeting Union government needs. Its earlier letters (on December 20 and 27 and January 7) soliciti comments from the states elicited limited response, prompting it to revise the proposal in the January 12 letter. Earlier last year, the DoPT had cautioned the states that not sending enough officers may affect future cadre review proposals. The Centre is apparently unable to fill vacancies at director and joint secretary levels in various Union ministries. Among the Central Secretariat Service (CSS) posts lying vacant, 390 are at joint secretary level (experience of 19-plus years) and 540 are for deputy secretary (nine years) or director ranks (14 years of service).

At stake now is the move to amend Rule 6 of the IAS (Cadre) Rules, 1954, which governs central deputation in the IAS. According to it, an AIS officer can be posted at the Centre with the concurrence (no objection certificate) of the concerned state governm­ent. The DoPT asks states to send an annual list of names of AIS officers willing to go on central deputation, from which it then selects officers. The new proposal is prompted by a persistent shortage of off­icers on central deputation. As of January 1, 2021, only 458 IAS officers were on central deputation out of around 5,200 IAS officers in the country. Indeed, some states have nominated very few officers for deputation to the Centre. Madhya Pradesh (with just 24 of 370 IAS officers on central deputation), West Bengal (28 out of 298), Rajasthan (12 out of 241) and Telangana (9 out of 164) are conspicuous on this list (see Cadrewise Breakup of IAS Officers). In fact, actual deputation as a percentage of the mandated reserves fell from 69 per cent in 2014 to 30 per cent in 2021, suggesting that the DoPT has a valid concern.

EARLIER CHANGES

The DoPT has already made two significant changes in less than a decade. In August 2017, the Union government revised the cadre allocation policy, ostensibly to ensure national integration of the bureaucracy and ensure an all-India character for the services. The existing state cadre were divided into five zones. Under the policy, a candidate has to first give their choice in descending order of preference from among the zones. Subsequently, they have to indicate a preferred cadre from each selected zone. The second cadre preference for every preferred zone is indicated subsequently. The process continues till the candidate exhausts the list. No change is permitted afterwards. Officers continue to work in the cadre they are allotted or are deputed to the Government of India. In 2020, to ensure more officers at the Centre, the DoPT made it mandatory for IAS officers from the 2007 batch on to serve at least three years on central deputation at the level of deputy secretary and above in order to be considered for empanelment and appointment in higher ranks—as a joint secretary, additional secretary or secretary.

Now, Delhi wants to acquire overriding power if the state delays sending an officer on central deputation. It has proposed that “the officer shall stand relieved from cadre from the date as may be specified by the central government”.

The problem is that the majority of bureaucrats are comfortable staying in the states. But central deputation of the AIS officers, be it IAS or IPS, ensures a two-way movement of officers which is beneficial for the states as well the Union government. It also enhances domain expertise of individual officers and widens their experience.

COMBATIVE FEDERALISM

The states, though, view the move with suspicion. West Bengal chief minister Mamata Banerjee was the first to assert her opposition in a letter to the prime minister on January 13. In her third letter on the issue, she called it a draconian move, emphasising that the proposed amendment is against the “spirit of cooperative federalism”, “taking the matter to non-federal extremes” besides being against the “basic structure of India’s constitutional scheme”.

Banerjee knows all too well what central interference can mean. Last year, the DoPT directed West Bengal chief secretary Alapan Bandyopadhyay to report to its office in Delhi hours after the chief minister allegedly skipped a review meeting on Cyclone Yaas with Prime Minister Narendra Modi. The 1987 batch IAS officer, who had never been on central deputation, was to superannuate on May 31. He is now fighting a case against the Centre.

The Centre’s proposal has provoked other chief ministers too to join the chorus. Tamil Nadu’s M.K. Stalin points out that it empowers the Centre to enlist any officer without the concurrence of the concerned state and place them “in perpetual fear of being penalised by the Union government at any time”. Jharkhand’s Hemant Soren argues it will create a fear psychosis in an IAS officer and adversely affect his “objectivity, performance and efficiency” and prevent him from offering candid opinion in matters that can be construed as “taking sides in sensitive matters of Centre-state disputes”.

Yet others invoke the federal spirit to claim it is an attempt to undermine the states’ authority. Chhattisgarh chief minister Bhupesh Baghel warns that if implemented, it may lead to the collapse of the administrative system of states. He claims that as a result of the amendments, officers posted in various important capacities will be assailed by a sense of instability and ambiguity. “They will be in a dilemma while discharging their duties and due to political interference, it will not be possible for them to work impartially, particularly at the time of elections,” says Baghel. The protests, of course, are largely from non-BJP-ruled states.

What the states find most galling is that while New Delhi seeks to consult the states on the number of officers to be deputed to the Centre, it wants overriding powers in case of any disagreement. With similar proposals for the IPS and IFoS, the states are apprehensive that this is an attempt to subvert their authority guaranteed by the Constitution.

OFFICERS' PLIGHT

The bureaucrats are in a quandary and, in private, fear the proposed changes expose them to reprisal. A major con­cern is the Union government arrogating to itself the authority to seek the services of any IAS officer for a central assignment. In effect, a bureaucrat perceived to be close to a rival party government can be brought to Delhi as a punitive measure.

But some do endorse the proposal. “Camaraderie and cooperation among the Union and the states cannot, like federalism, be a one-sided construct. It cuts both ways,” argues Srivatsa Kri­shna, a 1994 batch IAS officer now on a sabbatical. “The Government of India (GoI) cannot run effectively with just 458 IAS officers serving it. The quality of governance, indeed of both policy design and execution, depends a lot on the hand at the wheel.” He says any state treating AIS officers as officers of the state are flouting existing norms. Further, he asks, should the GoI not have the option of selecting specific officers for special situations, especially now when they are even bringing in professionals from the private sector?

Many, however, remain wary of the Centre’s intentions. “India is a Union of states and that is how we have a central governm­ent. What is being attempted is to convert an All India Service as one under a centralised authority,” rues retired bure­aucrat and author M.G. Devasahayam.

Others say the problem goes deeper and involves the essential subjugation of an already much co-opted civil service. “When the Centre itself is pushing for lateral entry, what is the need for calling unwilling officers on deputation?” asks Ajit Kumar Singh, a retired IAS officer of Rajasthan. “This move will demoralise IAS officers and the services will lose their sheen in course of time. Short-sighted decisions can do long-term damage to the polity.” Yet others say that the problem is that a majority of officers do not want to work outside their state. They cite two reasons for it. One, the empanelment process is itself pitted against those going to the Union government. Two, the cadre develop a comfort in the state and do not want to take on an unknown (the Centre). Consequently, the AIS has effectively devolved into the provincial services.

“There is no premium on competence in the civil service. That is the problem. It is a self-imposed characteristic or virtue rather than externally demanded. What is demanded by bosses is only subservience,” emphasises P.V. Ramesh, who retired from the Andhra Pradesh cadre. People choose to refer to the IAS as the steel frame but actually it is no frame at all, he says, likening bureaucrats to multiple amoebae put in a bowl and moving in different directions.

Ramesh suggests an overhaul of the governance structure (which has not been attempted in the past 75 years) as the IAS is too small for a complex country of 1.4 billion people. His solution: do not allot to a cadre for the first 12-14 years when you are expected to do field service and earn your spurs to go to the next level. At that stage, let an independent national civil service authority appraise performance along with the UPSC and decide the direction in which each one should go. Also make it mandatory for the officer to work with the Union government for a couple of years and only on completing it should the officer be allotted to any state. He feels the staff position should be national in an All India Service in order to have a bureaucracy that is independent and stands up for the rule of law while being part of the nation-building enterprise.

- With Amitabh Srivastava, Rohit Parihar and Romita Datta


Football news:

सउदी ने सभी के बाद न्यूकैसल खरीदा। अधिकांश प्रशंसकों की छुट्टी होती है, मानवाधिकार कार्यकर्ताओं के पास प्रीमियर लीग के लिए प्रश्न होते हैं । .
न्यूकैसल के लिए खरीदा गया था सउदी से एक ही लड़की जो लाया शेखों आदमी के लिए शहर छोड़ दिया और ब्रिटिश राजकुमार के लिए स्वतंत्रता
फ्रांस-राष्ट्र संघ के फाइनल में:बेल्जियम के साथ 0:2 से अधिक हो गया, थियो हर्नांडेज़ ने 90 वीं जीत हासिल की (अपने भाई के साथ शुरुआत में बाहर आया) । .
प्रीमियर लीग का मानना है कि सऊदी अरब ने क्लब, शीयर नहीं खरीदा और प्रशंसक खुश हैं, मीडिया में एक भारी प्रतिबिंब है: न्यूकैसल के संवर्धन के बाद दुनिया । .
Tutberidze की खोज में जोड़ी स्केटिंग: तारासोवा और Morozov बदला कार्यक्रम - और Gleichengauz दुख की बात है कि उनके विचारों में फिट नहीं था वहाँ
रूसी फुटबॉल खिलाड़ी-मेमे - फीफा 2 में धीरज में शीर्ष 22। थकान एक भ्रम है । .
सबसे तेज़ शहरी ट्रैक एफ -1 के निर्माण के माध्यम से एक अनूठा मार्ग: इसे ग्रैंड प्रिक्स के लिए $ 660 मिलियन के लिए तैयार किया जा रहा है, शुरुआत 2 महीने में है । .

3:19 'Every Seat Can't Be Paid': Consumer Affairs Ministry Raises Alarm on Unfair Airline Practices, Calls for Action
3:05 Congress leader Sushilkumar Shinde announces retirement yet again, says daughter Praniti will contest 2024 Lok Sabha poll from Solapur
3:03 Ramesh Narayan: AFAA ने 23 वर्षों के अथक परिश्रम के लिए रमेश नारायण को Honorary Life Member पुरस्कार से किया सम्मानित
2:53 Polish paraglider goes missing in Kangra valley, case registered against training school
2:51 Golden jubilee celebrations of women’s police station begin
2:50 Israel: प्रधानमंत्री बेंजामिन नेतन्याहू का बेटा कहां पर है? हमास से लड़ाई के बीच जानिए क्यों हो रही इसकी चर्चा
2:47 टीवी बहस के दौरान BRS विधायक ने पकड़ा भाजपा उम्मीदवार का गला, हाथापाई की, वायरल हुआ वीडियो
2:46 Motorcyclist fatally knocked down by car
2:46 ISRO चीफ ने सोमनाथ ने लिखी अपनी आत्मकथा, कहा- युवा होंगे इससे प्रेरित
2:45 Hijab Allowed for K’taka Govt Recruitment Tests, Not in Schools, Clarifies Higher Edu Min | Exclusive
2:42 Koffee With Karan 8: Ranveer Singh reveals he 'went through a lot' after his three consecutive 'major' flops
2:38 Water supply to be disrupted in Thiruvananthapuram
2:35 Biodiversity board eyes innovative solutions to conservation through ideation challenge
2:27 Breaking: 22 killed, several wounded in mass shooting at Maine in US, pic of shooter surfaces
2:26 US Shooting: अमेरिका के लेविस्टन शहर में भीषण गोलीबारी में 22 की मौत, 50 से ज्यादा घायल, हमलावर फरार
2:21 Busy Day For PM Modi: Shirdi Sai Temple Visit to National Games Inauguration in Goa Today
2:21 इजराइल के साथ सीधे जंग में उतरने के लिए कितना सक्षम है ईरान
2:18 US Shooting: अमेरिका के लेविस्टन शहर में भीषण गोलीबारी में 16 की मौत, 60 से ज्यादा घायल, हमलावर फरार
2:15 ‘Bharat’ shows the real identity of our country, say experts
2:14 Major fire breaks out in Secunderabad’s Navketan Complex, no casualties
2:14 Explainer: What is Sky Bus? Know everything about soon to be launched service in India
2:04 Karan Johar wants to remake this blockbuster romantic drama with Ranveer Singh, Deepika Padukone, Ranbir Kapoor
2:02 युद्ध के बीच इजराइल की मांग, हमास को आतंकी संगठन घोषित करे भारत
2:00 Delhi-NCR in Pollution Chokehold, Hospitals Flooded by Patients with Respiratory Problems
1:54 PRAGATI Meeting: 31 हजार करोड़ के आठ प्रोजेक्ट की PM मोदी ने की समीक्षा, हर गांव में खुलेंगे विकास के नए मार्ग
1:54 PM Modi to inaugurate India Mobile Congress on October 27, check details
1:44 US Shooting: अमेरिका के लेविस्टन शहर में सामूहिक गोलीबारी में 16 की मौत, 60 से ज्यादा घायल, हमलावर फरार
1:21 PM Modi to attend inauguration of Ram Temple in Ayodhya on Jan 22, Muslim leaders demand...
1:18 India-Canada row: India to resume visa services in Canada for four categories
1:16 Siddharth P Malhotra on Pashminna: I wanted to make a love story in Kashmir without military or terrorism | Exclusive
1:15 Bollywood: छोटे से रोल ने दिलाई बड़ी पहचान... एक्ट्रेस Poonam Dhillon ने शेयर किया Karma फिल्म का एक्सपीरियंस
1:13 12th Fail review: Vikrant Massey, Medha Shankar pass with distinction in Vidhu Vinod Chopra's emotional, inspiring tale
1:00 कॉमेडियन कपिल शर्मा के शो की वापसी में हुई देरी:अब अगले साल चैनल 'द कपिल शर्मा शो' को री-लॉन्च करने की प्लानिंग में जुटा
0:58 Morning Digest | A month after suspension, India resumes visas for Canadians in some categories; PM Modi to attend inauguration of Ram Temple in Ayodhya on January 22, and more
0:37 Teesta Setalvad: तीस्ता सीतलवाड़ की याचिका पर गुजरात हाईकोर्ट में हुई सुनवाई, सरकार को जारी किया नोटिस; कही ये बात
0:33 karnataka: कर्नाटक में फर्जी पहचान पत्र के मामले की जांच सीबीआई-एनआईए से कराई जाए, भाजपा ने रखी अपनी मांग
0:26 Sharad Purnima 2023: Follow these 5 Rituals to please goddess Lakshmi on this day
0:25 Meet IRS Komal Ganatra, woman earning just Rs 5000 monthly prepared for UPSC from village, bagged AIR...
0:20 PM Modi: पीएम मोदी आज महाराष्ट्र को देंगे कई परियोजनाओं की सौगात, गोवा में राष्ट्रीय खेलों का करेंगे उद्घाटन
0:08 Delhi : प्रदूषण रोकने के लिए रेड लाइट ऑन-गाड़ी ऑफ अभियान आज से, आईटीओ चौराहे से होगी शुरुआत
0:08 After U.S., U.K., Australia, Five eyes member New Zealand too criticises India on order expelling Canadian diplomats
0:00 जेल में रोज संजय दत्त को दुआएं देते थे:खाने के बाद डायरिया हो जाता था; राज कुंद्रा के बगल में कैदी बीड़ी पीते थे
0:00 बॉलीवुड एक्ट्रेसेस का कार कलेक्शन:श्रद्धा कपूर ने खरीदी 4 करोड़ की लैंबॉर्गिनी, 5.25 करोड़ की रोल्स रॉयस घोस्ट में चलती हैं प्रियंका चोपड़ा
0:00 फादर ऑफ मलयाली सिनेमा जे.सी. डेनियल:जमीन बेचकर पहली फिल्म बनाई, दलित हीरोइन लेने पर लोगों ने जान लेनी चाही, जिंदगी भर गुमनामी में रहे
23:49 Pandal snack? 600 phuchkas used as decorations go missing
23:30 Aaj Ka Panchang, 26 October, 2023: Tithi, Vrat, Rahu Kaal, and Other Details
23:02 EC to appoint ‘Newton’ actor Rajkummar Rao as National Icon
22:52 BJP condemns attack on party candidate
22:49 Mumbai septuagenarian couple loses ₹4 crore in 4 months in cyber fraud
22:16 Telangana के BJP विधायक टी राजा सिंह को मिली अज्ञात नंबर से धमकी, कहा- 15 अंकों का नंबर इस्लामिक देश का है
22:00 In its fourth list, BJP announces remaining four candidates for Chhattisgarh elections
21:58 Gaza War: गाजा में संघर्षविराम पर नहीं बनी सहमति, रूस-चीन ने यूएनएससी में अमेरिका के प्रस्ताव पर किया वीटो
21:51 Set up mobile towers in all villages by March 2024: PM Modi
21:50 SC urges judges to ‘follow discipline’ while taking up cases
21:43 Crushed by inflation, populace using loans to make ends meet: Congress
21:29 NC’s high-powered committee sets up task force to fight drug abuse in Kashmir
21:19 Government to organise Hackathon on 5G technology for law enforcement, discuss 360-degree surveillance and predictive policing 
21:14 India's first all-woman police station celebrates 50 years
21:12 Priyanka made “false claims” about PM’s “personal religious devotion”, BJP tells ECI
21:09 Reintroduce in BNS adultery section in gender-neutral form, says panel
21:08 Israel Hamas War: गाजा में इस्राइली सेना की भारी बमबारी, पत्रकार के परिवार समेत कई लोगों की मौत
20:57 Shivraj, Kamal Nath prepare for crucial polls as BJP, Congress deal with factional protests in M.P.
20:57 All bets are off in Madhya Pradesh fight
20:54 JD(U) releases first list of five candidates for Madhya Pradesh
20:53 PM Modi to attend inauguration of Ram Temple in Ayodhya on January 22
20:44 One month on, India resumes some visa services for Canadians
20:40 Civilian casualties in ongoing Israel-Palestine conflict matter of serious, continuing concern: India tells UN Security Council
20:35 To criticise plaques on heritage is ‘wrong, ridiculous’: Visva-Bharati 
20:30 Karan Johar: आखिर करण जौहर ने क्यों नहीं की शादी, वजह जानकर रह जाएंगे हैरान
20:25 Free arrested activists or face ‘jail bharo’, says U.P. Dalit rights group
20:22 AAP Gujarat chief to return to journalism with new TV show
20:20 No immunity if platforms fail to remove child sex content?
20:20 Time has come for India to declare Hamas as a terrorist group: Israeli Ambassador Naor Gilon
20:18 In a first, Army gets vertical wind tunnel to train special forces
20:18 PRAGATI Meeting: पीएम मोदी ने की आठ परियोजनाओं की समीक्षा, कहा- सभी गांवों में की जाए मोबाइल टावर की स्थापना
20:11 EU eyes stronger India ties by posting military attache
20:04 Ram temple consecration on January 22, PM Modi to attend
19:46 Law Commission presents roadmap on ‘One Nation, One Election’ to Ram Nath Kovind-led panel
19:41 Incident at Raj Bhavan because of DMK’s irresponsibility, says O. Panneerselvam
19:38 Israel-Hamas War: 'हमास आम नागरिकों को युद्ध के लिए आगे कर रहा', इजरायली राजदूत नाओर गिलोन का बयान
19:35 Exploring legal action in the issue of vacant medical seats, says Tamil Nadu Health Minister 
19:33 While experts pitch for death penalty abolition, panel leaves call to government
19:31 Registrations open for Shaastra 2024 contests for school and college students
19:26 Not Deepika Padukone, but this actress was originally cast opposite Ranveer Singh in Goliyon Ki Raasleela Ram-Leela
19:18 Drastic and serious attack on Constitutional Head of the State of Tamil Nadu, says Raj Bhavan
19:17 Stalls selling books on politics, secularism a big draw during Durga Puja
19:14 Mizoram Elections : मिजोरम में चुनाव के लिए 3000 पुलिसकर्मी और केंद्रीय बलों के 5000 से ज्‍यादा कर्मी होंगे तैनात
19:08 Wonderla commences work on its project near Chennai (photo emailed)
18:55 Elangovan flays EPS over remarks on Dravidian, Aryan races
18:54 CEO chairs meeting of political parties
18:53 AIADMK embarks on an outreach in southern districts, the stronghold of the party once 
18:53 अश्लील वीडियो मामला : किरीट सोमैया ने दानवे व चैनल के खिलाफ दायर किया मानहानि का मुकदमा
18:47 ஐ.நா. பொதுச்செயலர் பதவி விலக வேண்டும்: இஸ்ரேல் தூதர் வலியுறுத்தல்
18:46 அகவிலைப்படி 4 சதவீதம் உயர்வு; அரசுக்கு ரூ.2,546 கோடி கூடுதல் செலவு
18:42 Headmistress, teachers suspended on charge of bogus admissions
18:41 लोकसभा, विधानसभा ही नहीं, पंचायत और निकाय चुनाव भी साथ कराने की गुंजाइश तलाशेगी कोविंद समिति!
18:29 1,593 students found to be severely anaemic in Faridabad
18:26 Rajinikanth के पोस्ट पर Amitabh Bachchan ने किया रिप्लाई, बोले- 'मैं अपनी तुलना आपसे नहीं कर सकता'
18:24 HC Refuses to Grant Permission to Hold Event at Ramlila Maidan, Says Posters Indicate Communal Overtones
18:24 Soumya Vishwanathan Murder Case: Delhi Court Likely to Pronounce Order on Sentence on Thursday