Lawyers blame ChatGPT for tricking them into citing bogus case law Loop Jamaica

Two apologetic lawyers responding to an angry judge in Manhattan federal court blamed ChatGPT Thursday for tricking them into including fictitious legal research in a court filing.

Attorneys Steven A. Schwartz and Peter LoDuca are facing possible punishment over a filing in a lawsuit against an airline that included references to past court cases that Schwartz thought were real but were actually invented by the artificial intelligence-powered chatbot.

Schwartz explained that he used the groundbreaking program as he hunted for legal precedents supporting a client’s case against the Colombian airline Avianca for an injury incurred on a 2019 flight.

The chatbot, which has fascinated the world with its production of essay-like answers to prompts from users, suggested several cases involving aviation mishaps that Schwartz hadn’t been able to find through usual methods used at his law firm.

The problem was, several of those cases weren’t real or involved airlines that didn’t exist.

Schwartz told US District Judge P. Kevin Castel he was “operating under a misconception … that this website was obtaining these cases from some source I did not have access to.”

He said he “failed miserably” at doing follow-up research to ensure the citations were correct.

“I did not comprehend that ChatGPT could fabricate cases,” Schwartz said.

Microsoft has invested some $1 billion in OpenAI, the company behind ChatGPT.

Its success, demonstrating how artificial intelligence could change the way humans work and learn, has generated fears from some. Hundreds of industry leaders signed a letter in May that warns ” mitigating the risk of extinction from AI should be a global priority alongside other societal-scale risks such as pandemics and nuclear war.”

Judge Castel seemed both baffled and disturbed at the unusual occurrence and disappointed the lawyers did not act quickly to correct the bogus legal citations when they were first alerted to the problem by Avianca’s lawyers and the court. Avianca pointed out the bogus case law in a March filing.

The judge confronted Schwartz with one legal case invented by the computer program. It was initially described as a wrongful death case brought by a woman against an airline only to morph into a legal claim about a man who missed a flight to New York and was forced to incur additional expenses.

“Can we agree that’s legal gibberish?” Castel asked.

Schwartz said he erroneously thought that the confusing presentation resulted from excerpts being drawn from different parts of the case.

When Castel finished his questioning, he asked Schwartz if he had anything else to say.

“I would like to sincerely apologize,” Schwartz said.

He added that he had suffered personally and professionally as a result of the blunder and felt “embarrassed, humiliated and extremely remorseful.”

He said that he and the firm where he worked — Levidow, Levidow & Oberman — had put safeguards in place to ensure nothing similar happens again.

LoDuca, another lawyer who worked on the case, said he trusted Schwartz and didn’t adequately review what he had compiled.

After the judge read aloud portions of one cited case to show how easily it was to discern that it was “gibberish,” LoDuca said: “It never dawned on me that this was a bogus case.”

He said the outcome “pains me to no end.”

Ronald Minkoff, an attorney for the law firm, told the judge that the submission “resulted from carelessness, not bad faith” and should not result in sanctions.

He said lawyers have historically had a hard time with technology, particularly new technology, “and it’s not getting easier.”

“Mr Schwartz, someone who barely does federal research, chose to use this new technology. He thought he was dealing with a standard search engine,” Minkoff said. “What he was doing was playing with live ammo.”

Daniel Shin, an adjunct professor and assistant director of research at the Center for Legal and Court Technology at William & Mary Law School, said he introduced the Avianca case during a conference last week that attracted dozens of participants in person and online from state and federal courts in the US, including Manhattan federal court.

He said the subject drew shock and befuddlement at the conference.

“We’re talking about the Southern District of New York, the federal district that handles big cases, 9/11 to all the big financial crimes,” Shin said. “This was the first documented instance of potential professional misconduct by an attorney using generative AI.”

He said the case demonstrated how the lawyers might not have understood how ChatGPT works because it tends to hallucinate, talking about fictional things in a manner that sounds realistic but is not.

“It highlights the dangers of using promising AI technologies without knowing the risks,” Shin said.

The judge said he’ll rule on sanctions at a later date.

By Larry Neumeister


Football news:

<!DOCTYPE html>
Kane on Tuchel: A wonderful man, full of ideas. Thomas in person says what he thinks
Zarema about Kuziaev's 350,000 euros a year in Le Havre: Translate it into rubles - it's not that little. It is commendable that he left
Aleksandr Mostovoy on Wendel: Two months of walking around in the middle of nowhere and then coming back and dragging the team - that's top level
Sheffield United have bought Euro U21 champion Archer from Aston Villa for £18.5million
Alexander Medvedev on SKA: Without Gazprom, there would be no Zenit titles. There is a winning wave in the city. The next victory in the Gagarin Cup will be in the spring
Smolnikov ended his career at the age of 35. He became the Russian champion three times with Zenit

22:01 63 PPV Operators Charged for Excess Fares
22:00 ‘Shaft’ star Richard Roundtree dies at 81
21:58 Increased Access to Justice for PWDs
21:55 National Partnership Council to be Institutionalised
21:45 Chang stands firm on 'shoot to kill' comments
21:31 Woman charged for harbouring fugitive boyfriend
21:21 Medical missions in spotlight after Tufton’s dental care comments Loop Jamaica
20:57 Gas prices up $0.25, diesel down $0.90
20:56 Privy Council grants Vybz Kartel ‘expedited hearing’ Loop Jamaica
20:31 Roshawn Clarke’s world U20 400m hurdles record ratified Loop Jamaica
20:27 Trump called to testify in gag order dispute, fined $10,000 by judge in New York fraud trial
19:53 Ministry Wants Collective Effort to Combat Praedial Larceny
19:44 Tertiary Institutions to be Included in Apprenticeship Programme
19:37 SRC’S Conversations in Science Series Turns Spotlight on Men’s Mental Health
19:14 St. Catherine community protests fare increase, road and water issues
18:41 Privy Council grants Vybz Kartel expedited hearing
17:54 Fisherman charged with cocaine possession gets November court date
16:38 JUTC to Roll out Six New Buses by Month-End
16:30 NHF Adds Five New Health Conditions to Card Programme
16:24 NSWMA Pleased with Support for E-Waste Expo
16:23 Jamaican\Canadian Man’s Bullet-Riddled Body Discovered In Salt River Clarendon
16:20 Mother Researched Ways To Kill Before Strangling Her 3 Kids
16:16 Richard Roundtree, “Shaft” actor, dies at age 81
16:12 Biden officials shelve plan to require some migrants to remain in Texas after local backlash
16:08 Poison specialist Connor Bowman fatally poisoned his pharmacist wife and tried to stop autopsy, Minnesota authorities say
16:04 3 children, 1 adult killed in Canada shooting; wounded victim survives
13:26 Regional Consultation on Caribbean Moves Underway
13:25 18 Students Recognised for Academic Achievement
13:12 Gov’t Upskilling Labour Force – PM
10:21 Jamaicans expect crime situation to worsen next year - survey
10:04 Fire victim wins lottery
10:04 Child injured as parents squabble
10:04 Wife saved my life - Male breast cancer survivor credits spouse for spotting danger
9:11 Charles praises Canadian Farm Work Programme
7:40 Jamaican Parliament again calls for lifting of US embargo on Cuba
5:11 Holness maintains tight grip on AG’s opinion re tabling of reports
5:10 Crime slicing and dicing confidence
5:07 Man dies awaiting sentencing in lockup
5:05 Jamaica raising new debt on global markets, to pay down bonds worth US$1.7b
5:05 JBDC targets 2,000 smallbiz for digital upskilling
2:57 Safaree Shocked By Amara La Negra’s Crude Text About Vonshae’s Child On LHH Miami
0:56 Jesus shines for Arsenal in 2-1 win over Sevilla in Champions League Loop Jamaica
23:51 After off-duty Alaska Airlines pilot is accused of crash attempt, an air safety expert weighs in on how airlines screen their pilots
23:47 Man tried to burn Ohio church because of planned drag events
20:08 Mixed views on news of AA flights to Ian Fleming Int'l Airport
5:11 Millions lost in concession abuse
5:11 State offers $6m to man locked up for 50 years without trial
5:08 GOJ promises new customs law, highlights benefits of contactless processing through agency
5:08 Jamaica rum battle has a French twist
5:08 Kemtek marketing new residential complex, warns price will fluctuate with forex rate
16:59 Havertz scores his first Arsenal goal in 4-0 win over Bournemouth Loop Jamaica
16:42 Fans jeer as Manchester United lose 1-0 to Crystal Palace Loop Jamaica
16:29 Man City’s winning start to the EPL season ends in 2-1 loss at Wolves Loop Jamaica
12:46 Former MP believes term limits for Prime Minister should have flexibility for extension in certain circumstances
10:26 Residents join effort to block sale of land used by McCook school as playfield
9:24 JCF adds 257 new constables
5:10 Leon-Issa’s privacy fight to continue
4:37 PHOTOS: Minister Samuda Tours Jericho Pipeline Project
4:30 PHOTOS: JCDC FiWi Short Film Competition Award Ceremony
4:22 Gov’t Communication Being Streamlined
3:35 Road Closure Notice for the Withorn to Darliston Main Road in Westmoreland
23:48 Cuban Embassy In Washington, D.C. Attacked
22:41 Stocks Round Up | 108 stocks traded today
21:53 More Dengue cases recorded; one death confirmed
21:38 Mom hands over student accused of assault to police
18:56 Senator calls for death penalty for people who kill children
18:41 More than 1,200 pounds of ganja seized off St. Elizabeth coast
18:40 Michigan teen could spend life in prison for mass shooting
17:29 Man tied to suspected shooter in Tupac Shakur’s 1996 killing arrested in Las Vegas, AP sources say
17:09 Man allegedly attacked by Pava LaPere suspect recalls being set on fire as girlfriend raped
17:04 US Sen. Dianne Feinstein dead at 90
17:00 Man tied to suspected shooter in Tupac Shakur’s 1996 killing arrested Loop Jamaica
16:58 Man arrested in connection to 1996 murder of rapper Tupac Shakur
16:39 Man United Antony to resume playing after domestic abuse allegations Loop Jamaica
16:34 Advocates Association cautions against rush to dispose of court cases
16:32 May Pen hospital benefits from electronic health records Loop Jamaica
16:13 State of Emergency in effect as storm brings flooding, damage to New York City and beyond
16:07 Texas inmate on death row for nearly 30 years ruled not competent to be executed
16:02 1 wounded in shooting at protest over New Mexico statue of Spanish conquistador
15:57 Angry customer and auto shop owner shoot each other to death, Florida police say
14:20 National Cybersecurity Authority in Two to Four Years
14:07 Donald Trump loses bid to delay trial in New York fraud case
14:05 Toronto cop admits to helping mentees cheat in promotion interviews
14:03 More Than 100,000 Jamaicans to Be Trained in Good Parenting This Year
14:01 Dominica sets up investigative unit to probe arms trafficking
14:00 Garbage pile-up still affecting some communities
13:51 Senior Citizens Recognised in St. Elizabeth
12:44 Prospects dim as US scrambles to avoid government shutdown
12:33 No cash stolen in attack on courier vehicle in Manchester - police
10:06 Security guard wounded during attack on courier vehicle in Manchester
10:04 Court hears ... Woman beaten outside court
10:04 Cancer-stricken mom searches for missing daughter
10:04 Attorney pleads for diabetic client’s release
5:10 NCB rings in changes as more top execs move
5:10 Lesbian minister catering to LGBTQ+ people’s spirituality
5:08 Seprod gets shareholder nod to create new shares
5:07 Portland Fund III to deploy one-third of funds to women-led companies
5:06 Cruise terminal to be built on Folly lands in Portland
21:59 Florida teen who was struck by lightning while hunting with her dad has died
21:54 Trump’s legal team asks to delay deadlines in special counsel’s election interference case