Tycoon’s bid to halt Marble Arch Hotel’s demolition rejected

Counties

Tycoon’s bid to halt Marble Arch Hotel’s demolition rejected

Tuesday May 31 2022

Marble Arch Hotel. FILE PHOTO | NMG

A judge has dismissed a petition by tycoon Mike Maina seeking to block Nairobi County from demolishing Marble Arch Hotel.

Justice Lucy Mbugua of the Environment and Land Court dismissed the case, saying the businessman did not exhaust available dispute resolution mechanisms before rushing to court.

The tycoon moved to court in 2018 after former Nairobi governor Mike Sonko threatened to demolish the three-star hotel, claiming that it stands on public land and was built without approvals from the county government.

The former governor had also demolished a perimeter wall adjacent to the hotel saying the land, which the tycoon uses as a parking facility, was also public land. Mr Sonko later marked the hotel’s walls for demolition with the words ‘illegal’.

ALSO READ: Tycoon, Prisons land row heads to Court of Appeal

“It follows that the issues raised by the petitioner sought to be addressed through the dispute resolution mechanisms available under the relevant statutes and in an ordinary suit,” said Justice Mbugua.

The judge said the tycoon moved to court without following the laid down dispute resolution mechanisms.

The businessman wanted the court to declare that he was the legal owner of the two plots and grant him a permanent order, restraining the county government from trespassing or demolishing the hotel.

Mr Maina also sought Sh2 million in damages, accusing the county officials of trespass.

He said he acquired the two plots in 1993 and 1995 and has been running the hotel since 1993 and using the adjacent plot as a parking lot. The businessman said he has dutifully paid rates, rent and other approvals and licences for the properties.

The tycoon argued that planned demolition did not have a basis and it was an infringement on his rights to own property. The notice, he said, was malicious and should be quashed. City Hall did not defend the case.

“The upshot of the findings of this court is that the suit is not merited and the same is hereby dismissed,” the judge said.

ALSO READ: Tycoon awarded Sh859m for demolished Spring Valley home

Mr Maina’s mansion was demolished in 2007 to pave the way for the construction of the Waiyaki Way-Redhill link road.

The State, however, was ordered to compensate the tycoon Sh859 million for the demolition.

Bulldozers tore down Mr Maina’s eight-bedroom mansion to make way for a bypass and he successfully sued for damages. The government has appealed against the judgment.

In his evidence, Mr Maina said he had spent Sh299 million to build the mansion and acquired the land for Sh80 million. The government, however, said Mr Maina had acquired the land unlawfully through fraud, misrepresentation and mistake.

It said the land was part of a road and that the government had acquired it in the early 1970s to build a 4.4-kilometre link road.

[email protected]


Football news:

<!DOCTYPE html>
Kane on Tuchel: A wonderful man, full of ideas. Thomas in person says what he thinks
Zarema about Kuziaev's 350,000 euros a year in Le Havre: Translate it into rubles - it's not that little. It is commendable that he left
Aleksandr Mostovoy on Wendel: Two months of walking around in the middle of nowhere and then coming back and dragging the team - that's top level
Sheffield United have bought Euro U21 champion Archer from Aston Villa for £18.5million
Alexander Medvedev on SKA: Without Gazprom, there would be no Zenit titles. There is a winning wave in the city. The next victory in the Gagarin Cup will be in the spring
Smolnikov ended his career at the age of 35. He became the Russian champion three times with Zenit

21:00 Crack down on fake degree certificates
21:00 Why digital platforms count for banks
21:00 It’s time to set realistic tax collection targets
18:13 Airtel increases mobile money transaction fees
12:37 Treasury wants companies to hire anti-money laundering officers
3:50 Apologizing for Colonial Injustices in Kenya is Extremely Difficult, says British Envoy
3:49 CJ Koome Proposes Alternative Sanctions for Prostitution Instead of Criminalization
3:00 Kamau Thugge: Kenya paying the price for overvalued shilling
21:00 Unpacking an insecure boss
5:06 MMTC to host Marathon in December
13:44 Worst? Dear BCLB, why is Cheza Gaming Ltd(Helabet) not paying punters winnings?
13:34 Chaza Gaming Ltd T/A HelaBet is about to be closed down, withdraw your money!
4:00 David Gicheru: The 'mitumba' fashionista at medic's table
15:03 Brewed Business Brilliance: Where Nairobi's Coffee Culture Fuels Executive Success
3:50 Maxine Wahome Trial: Neighbor, Estate Chairman Testify Asad Khan was Abusive Towards Girlfriends
3:49 MP Proposes Implementation of Internet Billing Meters Based on Consumption
3:47 CS Kindiki Names Condition for Restoring Security to Azimio Leaders
3:46 CJ Koome: Fines and Cash Bail Payments to be Processed in Open Court
3:30 Billionaire Philip Ndegwa family expands its empire with new deals
3:00 Tea farmers set for record Sh44 billion bonus
21:00 State opens doors for synthetic fabric manufacturers
21:00 Kenya among the top 10 users of Truecaller globally
21:00 Mdundo hit with Sh31.5m music copyright claim
3:50 Nairobi County Identifies 436 Flooding Hotspots ahead of El Niño Rains
3:49 Kenyans Urged To Check Their Credit Status
3:30 Cash outside banks hits an all-time high of Sh273.4bn
3:00 Procurement watchdog flags fresh Kenya Power meters tender
21:28 KCB bank, Police blasted for cover up in attempted murder by a bank official!
21:00 Role of data and analytics literacy in empowering corporate services
21:00 The delicate innovation-ethics balance
21:00 Enforce salary spending compliance by counties
12:00 Logistics firm Sendy goes into administration
8:50 HEARTBROKEN: Why i regret dating a policewoman, painful experience!
3:50 Revealed: Amount Paid to KRA Official to Release Contaminated Sugar to Kenyan Public
3:49 Petitioner Who Sought TikTok Ban Changes Tune: “We haven’t received a call from statehouse”
3:43 Hippo Attack Kills Sewer Worker in Naivasha Sparking Protests from Colleagues
3:42 Korea to Provide Maritime Training and Employment Opportunities for Kenyans
3:41 Two Men Sentenced For Abduction, Gang Rape in Nakuru
3:30 Treasury plans to scrap tax on early pension withdrawals
3:00 Food import bill overtakes machinery on duty waivers
21:00 Staff debt puts Kisii University cash at risk
21:00 How to make education tech work for all in Kenya
21:00 M-Pesa deal to hand ward in Kisumu health centre
13:00 Microlender fined Sh3m for data breach
11:45 Two Kenyan health startups picked for Google AI Growth Academy
3:50 Nairobi Woman Defrauded of Sh140,000 in Weight Loss Scam
3:49 President Ruto Disburses Medical Kits to Community Health Promoters in Nairobi
3:30 Employers’ headache as pay deductions cross two thirds
3:00 Kenya debt interest payments rise Sh231.6bn on weak shilling
21:00 Emergency fund: Seven steps to building your safety net by leveraging benefits of money market fund
21:00 Expend4ble: From Iconic franchise to most forgettable misfire
21:00 Why do I need to take mortgage insurance?
14:15 Airline to pay woman with disability Sh400,000 for discrimination
11:30 Kenya to build nuclear power plant from 2027
7:07 Hospital, kidney donor battle in court over Sh1.5m payment claim
7:07 Mishra’s Mediheal Hospital, kidney donor battle in court over Sh1.5m payment claim
3:50 Nairobi Plans to Dispose of 193 Unclaimed Bodies Next Month
3:49 Nairobi County Targets Ksh20 Billion in Self-Generated Revenue
3:47 Kenya Signs Film Promotion Partnership with Hollywood Invention Studios
3:41 Kenyan Public Urged To Learn Sign Language To Ease Communication
3:30 Nairobi climbs 13 places on cheapest cities for expats list
3:00 Record-high Treasury bill rates set stage for expensive loans
21:00 Why Robotic Process Automation is your firm's best bet for seamless transition
21:00 Techie eyes e-commerce pie with geofencing platform
21:00 Chest pain: How do I know I'm having a heart attack?
8:05 10/10: Mwale Medical and Technology City Secures a Deal to Expand to Ghana
4:00 Catherine Muraga: My love language is 'mutura'
3:50 Police Release PHOTOS of Suspect Wanted in Connection with Murder of Nairobi Hospital Director
3:49 Government Announces: Unused Leave Days Will Not Be Compensated
3:30 Mega project financiers face tax break suspension
3:00 Boost for banks as car buyers flock to auction yards
11:13 Dangerous American Military Contractor Gabriel Oser Of Valar Frontier sued for exposing his dogs to two Kenyans, almost killing them
4:00 Agnes Gathaiya’s unfinished books and obsession with chips
13:30 Kenya to leverage MICE as it targets bigger revenue share from tourism mix
3:56 Raila To Host Moses Kuria in Bondo Next Week
3:49 23 Year Old Student Charged With Operating a ‘Mchele Ring’ on Mirema Drive
3:49 Police Clearance Certificate Processing at DCI Headquarters Fully Restored After System Upgrade
3:49 Miguna: Time for Anti-Odinga Slavery Movement To Organize
3:30 Kenya diaspora workers now face mandatory welfare levy
3:15 Riding the Edge: Finding the Ultimate Betting Platform
3:12 How betting software is revolutionizing sports wagering for Nairobi enthusiasts
3:00 Nairobi hotels relish windfall from luxury suites scramble
3:00 Nairobi hotels relish windfall from presidential suites scramble during climate summit
21:00 Swedish music maestro advocates for cross-cultural collaboration
21:00 Kenya woos global tech giants with green energy data centres
21:00 Ongoing e-mobility drive posed to deliver economic and green scores
12:45 CFAO Motors launches two new Suzuki models
9:00 GDC inks geothermal advisory deal with Malawi
3:50 Why we are not Registered in Kenya, Worldcoin CEO Explains
3:49 Man United Fan Swears Off Eggs for Life After Cheating Death Following Arsenal’s Victory
3:43 Harambee Stars to Take on 2022 World Cup Hosts Qatar
3:42 Jalang’o, Four Other ODM MPs Expelled over Gross Misconduct
3:41 Passaris Fined Sh250k for Endorsing Ruto’s Finance Bill
3:30 Inside the multi-billion dollar deals at Nairobi climate summit
3:00 Banks eat old giants’ lunch in stockbrokers profit race
21:00 Africa climate leadership, a welcome battering ram
21:00 Allow salary payments in dollars to protect Kenyans from weak shilling
21:00 Let’s revitalise coffee, tea value chains
12:45 Bolt to inject Sh100 million in Kenya electric mobility race
12:00 Application window for Kenyan university, TVET student scholarships extended