Lawyer challenges provisions in the Administration of Judiciary Act

Lawyer Steven Kalali. File Photo

Kampala, Uganda | THE INDEPENDENT | City lawyer Steven Kalali has petitioned the Constitutional court challenging some provisions in the newly enacted Administration of Judiciary Act, saying they are discriminatory to some judicial officers as well as the rest of the public servants.

The Judiciary Administration Act came into force on June 19th, 2020 after President Yoweri Museveni assented to it. The act is meant to strengthen the Judiciary as an independent arm of government. The act provides for the continued payment of monthly salary to a retired Chief Justice and his deputy on top of receiving a lump sum package equivalent to 2.4 percent of his or her annual salary multiplied by five and the total number of years spent in service.

According to provisions in the same law, retired Justices of the Supreme Court, the Court of Appeal, the Principal Judge, and Judges of the High Court, will continue getting 80 percent of their salaries once they have clocked their respective mandatory ages of retirement. They will also get a lump-sum retirement benefit equivalent to 2.4 percent of their annual salary multiplied by five and their years of service.

They will also be entitled to state security, chauffeur-driven cars, and annual medical and housing allowances. The act excludes registrars and magistrates from the provision of security, cars, medical and housing allowances despite the fact that they will continue earning their monthly salary for life.

Now in his petition submitted before the constitutional court on Monday, Kalali argues that some of the provisions in the Judiciary Act are discriminatory against public servants in different government entities who are not entitled to the same emoluments upon retirement. This Kalali says is unconstitutional.

He notes that the act is also discriminatory in nature since it only favors judicial officers on the higher bench leaving out the junior officers when it comes to things like funeral expenses and other entitlements.

“That the Act providing retirement benefits with huge packages or more packages to members of the high bench to the exclusion of those from the lower bench is discriminatory and connotes selfishness which this court should not be seen to operationalize the same,” reads Kalali’s affidavit supporting the petition.

He argues that unless the contested provisions of the Act are nullified, they are likely to cause or promote disrespect among public servants including police officers and health workers because of the discriminatory privileges.

The constitutional court has already summoned the Attorney General, who is listed as the only respondent to the petition to file his defense within 15 days before the matter can be allocated to a panel of five Justices for hearing.

*****

URN


Football news:

<!DOCTYPE html>
Kane on Tuchel: A wonderful man, full of ideas. Thomas in person says what he thinks
Zarema about Kuziaev's 350,000 euros a year in Le Havre: Translate it into rubles - it's not that little. It is commendable that he left
Aleksandr Mostovoy on Wendel: Two months of walking around in the middle of nowhere and then coming back and dragging the team - that's top level
Sheffield United have bought Euro U21 champion Archer from Aston Villa for £18.5million
Alexander Medvedev on SKA: Without Gazprom, there would be no Zenit titles. There is a winning wave in the city. The next victory in the Gagarin Cup will be in the spring
Smolnikov ended his career at the age of 35. He became the Russian champion three times with Zenit

19:51 Rugumayo shows intent, takes charge at Uganda Golf Open
18:56 Netball plight worsens as NCS withdraws Certificate of Recognition from UNF 
18:48 Crested Cranes Faceoff Cameroon At the CAF Women’s Olympic qualifiers
18:00 Roke Telkom boosts children with cancer in Mbarara City
17:48 PSG reboot: 1xBet reveals the French club’s prospects for the new season
17:46 As old ghosts return to haunt UIA, will ED Mukiza survive?
17:27 Night of Glory coming to Uganda this Friday at Hockey grounds
17:10 MTN Uganda and Government commission new dormitory at Salama school for the blind
17:00 Divine Mercy school collaborates with Royal House of Fulbe for campus expansion
16:00 Centenary Bank scoops accolade at 30th Global Finance Awards
14:00 Fire guts St Theresa – Kisubi dormitory
13:09 Thrilling Absa Pro Am ends with Johnnie Walker II team victory
13:00 UNEB EXAMS: Old Kampala SS Headmaster arrested
10:52 MTN Uganda, First Lady Commission New Dormitory at Salama School For The Blind
10:26 CAF and PUMA Unveils Official Afcon Match Ball
10:08 Uganda Open: Rugumayo on the winning team at Pro-Am tournament 
13:02 Harmonize, Nyashinski thrill revelers at the Bell ObaFest
11:37 Using TikTok to make dreams come true, meet Claud Heavy who has made a fortune out of the platform
6:53 Government clears Nyege Nyege, morality encouraged
10:38 Jameson Hangout delivers another remarkable Bond & Connect experience headlined by Oladapo
9:01 Opposition MPs protest exemption of UPDF soldiers from wealth declaration
8:00 Gen Mbadi urges UPDF Air Force officers to guard reputation of the institution
7:00 CMI releases nine detained Muslims
6:00 UPC tasks government to fix flood disasters in urban areas
5:00 Mao tasks URSB to harmonize its registration system
4:00 Uganda denies sending 70 officials to UN assembly
3:00 Scientists urged to apply research in addressing Uganda’s problems
20:23 Wolves hand leaders first defeat while Arsenal win, Man United falls
20:13 Spurs grab dramatic win over nine-man Liverpool
17:00 Makindye East LC5 Council race candidate Mukasa loses bid to challenge election costs
16:00 IOC announces first-ever Climate Action Awards winners
15:00 We have punished Brig. Okoya’s killers – Museveni
14:03 Nyege Nyege announces the flavor of its 8th edition with an exquisitely adventurous line up
14:00 Right to information activists ask gov’t to restore facebook
13:00 Hello World: ISPs hold the key to empowering underserved communities
9:00 Education Minister issues guidelines on timeline for teacher degree requirement
8:00 UN report reveals systemic racism in U.S. police, justice systems
7:30 MASAKA: Logistical challenges hinder implementation of PDM
6:15 The fall and fall of the FDC
6:00 Government launches big Arabica Coffee growing campaign in Rukiga
5:00 Gov’t to introduce amendments to strengthen Anti-Corruption Law
3:00 Abortion-associated stigma affecting access to Post-Abortion Care – MOH
17:00 Busy Saturday in Premier League after Carabao Cup gives plenty to think about
16:00 Turkey’s Erdogan looks west to ease economic woes at home
15:00 DNA: Health ministry launches guidelines for testing
14:00 URSB starts campaign to popularize Insolvency Amendment Act, business registration
13:30 Hundreds flock Kololo grounds for annual Independence night prayers
13:17 RWANDA: 20 people killed, 58 more injured by rain-induced disasters in September
13:00 Political party drama and democracy
12:30 How to stop Africa health worker brain drain
12:00 Russia to increase defense spending in 2024: Kremlin
11:00 AfDB outlines steps Uganda needs to mobilize climate finance
10:00 Experts skeptical about Co-operative Bank revival
9:30 Health Ministry launches guidelines for DNA testing
9:00 Mulago to showcase specialized surgeries in free camp
7:00 Cabinet accepts UBOS decision to postpone national census
6:00 African top economist urges Uganda to fast-track oil and gas
5:00 URA directs city landlords to issue E-receipts
4:00 UPDATE: 24 students admitted at Soroti Hospital
3:00 Lukwago: ULC has no powers to allocate land
18:27 Foreign legion expected at UGC Ladies Open
16:00 US public schools see continuing enrollment drop
15:00 To protect democracy, revive local journalism
14:04 Doreen Mirembe: The heart and soul of Damalie
14:00 Kenneth Mugabi: Fun Factory gave me my big break
12:43 Zaake wins case against Uganda’s Speaker
11:00 Paediatric anaesthesia gets boost
10:00 Court to decide Kalali’s suit against ULS in December
9:08 President to launch Kiira Motors Electric Trike at National Science Week 2023
9:00 Entertainment and tourism need each other
8:00 ‘Men prefer receiving HIV Test kits from peers than testing at Hospitals’
6:00 UNFPA commits continued support to Uganda’s teenage pregnancy fight
5:00 Residents demand fresh evaluation as UPDF establishes airbase in Masaka
4:38 Buganda Kingdom to buy 2 million shares in Airtel Uganda IPO
3:00 DPRK to expel U.S. soldier over illegal border crossing
16:00 Nile Breweries unveils new campaign to fight alcohol abuse
15:00 Court gives Byarugaba permission to challenge Ayota’s NSSF appointment
14:04 Uganda, Kenya and Tanzania to host AFCON 2027
14:00 ICPAU roots for a ‘corporate leadership ready to lead change’
12:00 Uganda’s insurers commit to collaborative growth efforts
11:00 What awaits members at hastily called NRM Parliamentary Caucus meeting
10:00 Govt apologizes, offers compensation to family of accident victim on collapsed Kabale-Kisoro Road
9:00 Shadow cabinet punches holes in IGG’s Annual Performance Reports
8:00 Registrars concerned about growing disrespect from fellow judicial officers
7:00 Woman jailed 18 months for vehicle theft at Aponye’s burial
6:00 Mabirizi sues Kabaka again over Busuulu
5:30 Arsenal fans battling stomach complications after celebratory meal
5:06 Looking into why the President prefers a casual look even at official functions
3:00 One arrested, five Ugandans on the run for faking kidnap in South Sudan
17:00 Nyatho’s Mama Kafunda solo show
16:00 Eviction fears intensify among Makerere University canteen and kiosk owners
15:00 URSB targets 870,500 new business registrations by 2026/27 
14:10 Uganda’s NSSF declares 10% interest rate for FY 2022/23
13:00 The life of a community’s only ‘animal doctor’
12:00 Museveni queries delayed construction of Gulu University teaching hospital
11:00 No relocation funds to ‘Mother’ districts till FY 2024/25
10:00 Security forces in Karamoja on alert over Pokot threats
9:00 Russia places ICC president on Wanted list
8:00 Rwenzururu Kingdom struggling to raise resources for Omusinga home coming
7:00 Chinese lending to Africa remains below $2bn for second consecutive year