Ramaphosa: police must say why no Phala Phala case was opened

Answering questions in the National Assembly on Thursday, Ramaphosa said he reported the theft to a police general who later reported it to another general.

Asked by DA leader John Steenhuisen why no case number was ever given and no case opened, Ramaphosa responded: “I reported it as one would report and when you report to a police general you expect that processes will unfold in the way that they should. In the end, the police would be able to answer that question.”

African Transformation Movement leader Vuyo Zungula asked Ramaphosa, who earlier vouched for police efficiency, why he did not report the crime to the relevant and appropriate law enforcement institutions like all citizens and especially if he was genuine about eradicating crime.

“What message does it send to the nation when allegations of money laundering, kidnapping and torturing are all happening in the president’s farm and the president refuses to take the nation into his confidence?” asked Zungula.

Ramaphosa responded: “I have said and admitted that there was a theft at the farm and I reported that to a general of the SA police who later informed me that he’s also reported it to another general of the SA Police Service.

“That matter obviously is under processing within the police service, they are dealing with it,” he said. “I deny that there was any form of money laundering. I have said and I’ve said it more publicly that it was proceeds of sale of game.”

Ramaphosa reiterated that he was a cattle and game farmer for a number of years, a matter he had disclosed in parliament when he was deputy president and to the secretary of the cabinet when he became president.

That activity sometimes resulted in the sale of cattle as well as the sale of animals such as buffalo and sable.

“That is a matter that takes place from time to time, and even recently we’ve been able to conclude, my managers have concluded the process where a parcel of buffalo was also sold.

“That in my view is not money laundering. It is a process that goes on.”

Ramaphosa repeated that he is willing and prepared to account to parliament about the matter and to subject himself “to all manner of investigations as well as inquiries” and other processing.

“There is now a section 89 process which I have clearly and openly said I will co-operate with and I will co-operate to the fullest of my ability.

“This matter has been subjected to a number of investigations by a number of authorities. The last time I counted there were up to seven or eight authorities looking into this.”

The question and answer session continues.

TimesLIVE

Support independent journalism by subscribing to the Sunday Times. Just R20 for the first month.


Football news:

<!DOCTYPE html>
Kane on Tuchel: A wonderful man, full of ideas. Thomas in person says what he thinks
Zarema about Kuziaev's 350,000 euros a year in Le Havre: Translate it into rubles - it's not that little. It is commendable that he left
Aleksandr Mostovoy on Wendel: Two months of walking around in the middle of nowhere and then coming back and dragging the team - that's top level
Sheffield United have bought Euro U21 champion Archer from Aston Villa for £18.5million
Alexander Medvedev on SKA: Without Gazprom, there would be no Zenit titles. There is a winning wave in the city. The next victory in the Gagarin Cup will be in the spring
Smolnikov ended his career at the age of 35. He became the Russian champion three times with Zenit

3:15 Kruger Park beefs up security at Numbi Road after killing of German tourist
3:10 Western Cape weather forecast: Mostly clear with cool temps- Thursday, 26 October
3:10 Phophi Ramathuba takes the lead for Limpopo’s first female premier
3:08 Northern Cape weather forecast: Partly cloudy to clear skies – Thursday, 26 October
3:06 Limpopo weather forecast: Partly cloudy to clear skies – Thursday, 26 October
3:02 ROB ROSE: Scary October for Markus Jooste
3:00 Daily news update: SA’s egg supply, Senzo Meyiwa murder trial and vaping crisis
3:00 Slow electoral law process could impact announcement of election date
3:00 Sand mining company appeals against refusal of water licence in Philippi
2:55 Over a million South Africans have used the HIV prevention pill
2:55 GoldOne hostage situation ‘likely to further weaken SA’s already poor global standing’
2:40 Mafiosi miners hostage crisis reveals disturbing truths
2:30 ANC faces growing discontent ahead of 2024 elections
2:20 The paradox of inclusion: SA’s struggle with immigration and inequality
2:00 Daily Love Horoscope: Here’s what love has for you today – 26 October 2023
2:00 DINNER PARTY INTEL: Prime parking at Clifton — for a driver with deep pockets
1:51 From R18 550 to WHOPPING R169 880 for Rugby World Cup Final SEAT
1:15 Daily Horoscope: Here’s what’s in store for you today – Thursday, 26 October 2023
1:00 Israel-Hamas war already hitting regional economies: IMF chief
0:00 Palestinian sings to ‘block out’ roar of Israel strikes
21:34 DA: Gauteng Premier’s anti-corruption unit is grossly understaffed
21:23 Russia and China veto draft resolution on Gaza at UN
21:23 Russia and China veto draft resolution on Gaza at UN Security Council
21:09 Customs officials jailed after accomplice who swallowed 89 balls of cocaine turns state witness
21:00 ‘Frozen in time’ landscape discovered under Antarctic ice
20:54 Can I be allergic to some cats and not others?
20:47 Can I feed my cat mashed potatoes?
20:47 Instagram Reel: Can you predict the Rugby World Cup final battle results? [Video]
20:37 Can cats eat apple pie?
20:31 Trump fined $10,000 for violating gag order for a second time
20:24 Viral YouTube Short | Infant of expectant mother in Israeli airstrikes miraculously rescued [Video]
20:23 Can I feed my cat pecan pie?
20:14 EDITORIAL | The Samas is an expensive indulgence provincial government can ill-afford
20:10 24 hours in pictures, 25 October 2023
20:06 Tears and joy as miners return to the surface after hostage drama
20:01 Gauteng health department clarifies policy on free health care for migrant mothers
20:01 Scrutiny on child nutrition after deaths of seven children from ‘food poisoning’
20:01 Court orders custody inquiry after child is removed from uncles’ care
20:00 British ex-police officer jailed for child sex offences
19:58 Viral YouTube Short | An Israeli captive shares their experiences in Gaza [Video]
19:54 Are you storing your wine properly? Don’t make these amateur mistakes
19:51 Do cats need sunbathing to be healthy?
19:45 The River live updates: Lindiwe is still upset about the recent events
19:37 Uzalo live updates: A big brawl exposes Hlelo’s secret
19:37 Viral YouTube Short | A London woman attacks people who are supporting Palestinians [Video]
19:35 Muvhango live updates: Shaz is in the trenches as she comes to terms with bankruptcy
19:13 Infrastructure key to Namibia’s battery metal ambitions, miners say
19:13 Viral YouTube Short | Grief, sorrow after Palestinian girl discovers her mom’s body [Video]
19:12 Ex-minister Dipuo Peters flouted ethics code: committee
19:07 I'm not chasing executives away from SOEs, says Pravin Gordhan
19:04 UZALO: Tonight’s episode, 25 October 2023 [VIDEO]
19:00 GENERATIONS: Tonight’s episode, 25 October 2023 [VIDEO]
19:00 South Africa risks 15 000 deaths by 2050 if green transition delayed – study
18:59 WATCH: Leopard takes a stroll along Western Cape dam wall
18:57 Coronation dumps platinum stocks
18:57 Coronation dumps stocks in dying platinum sector
18:54 Competition watchdog must protect small businesses against big tech: Patel
18:49 Joburg Transport MEC Kenny Kunene launches new world-class tech for Metrobus fleet
18:48 Republican Mike Johnson elected US House speaker after weeks of infighting
18:40 WATCH: SA man conducts bathroom experiment shows how women with long nails wipe their bums, video goes viral
18:40 House of Zwide live updates: Zola professes his love for Zanele
18:30 MasterChef Australia announces new judge line-up after Jock Zonfrillo’s death
18:27 NIKIWE: Tonight’s episode, 25 October 2023 [VIDEO]
18:27 Cake-loving Ox Nche hopes for sweet taste of success in World Cup final
18:18 Renault to invest $3.2bn in eight new models for global relaunch
18:17 Daily Lotto results: Wednesday, 25 October 2023
18:09 Viral Video: Groomsmen entertaining guests at wedding has taken TikTok by storm
18:05 Drama as parrot predicts Springboks’ win in Rugby World Cup final (Video)
18:01 IEC ‘anxiously awaits’ Constitutional Court ruling on election law
18:00 Skeem Saam live updates: Pax dares Mahlatse to prove that he’s not scared of girls
17:57 Teen left church after prophecy from pastor who later 'sexually abused' him
17:55 Learner suicide: Grade 6 pupil found hanging after alleged bullying
17:54 Nissan unveils powerful electric GT-R concept
17:48 Johannesburg Water: Critically low reservoirs and towers listed
17:47 ‘I don’t mind being Nelson Mandela,’ says Donald Trump defending his legal battles
17:46 SCANDAL: Tonight’s episode, 25 October 2023 [VIDEO]
17:42 SA secures R19bn World Bank loan for energy transition
17:39 Banyana earn crucial 1-1 away draw with DRC in Olympic qualifier
17:38 Heineken on track but expects tough conditions in Nigeria
17:38 The CRAZY prices of 2023 Rugby World Cup final tickets
17:35 Australia drub the Dutch after Maxwell mayhem
17:34 HEATWAVE: Residents advised to stay out of the sun and hydrate
17:31 Shipbuilder’s owner blames Mozambique’s Nyusi for ‘tuna bond’ scandal
17:28 Lotto and Lotto Plus results: Wednesday, 25 October 2023
17:25 Brave Mzansi driver dodges hijackers with impressive driving skills (Video)
17:24 Western Cape push to repair storm damage before festive season rush
17:22 HOUSE OF ZWIDE: Tonight’s Episode for 25 October 2023 [VIDEO]
17:20 Banyana earn a crucial draw against lowly DR Congo
17:16 SKEEM SAAM: Tonight’s episode, 25 October 2023 [VIDEO]
17:08 Willie le Roux reflects on semifinal post-match fracas against England
17:05 Transition to clean energy ‘unstoppable’, report reads
17:00 Municipalities owe Rand Water billions of rand
16:54 Detectives pursue gunmen who killed three, injured fourth person in Cape Town
16:52 Argentina’s Patricia Bullrich signals support for Javier Milei in run-off
16:48 Who is to drive the Boks, Libbok or Pollard?
16:47 Johannesburg Water announces WATER SHUTDOWN in these suburbs until midnight
16:40 TS Galaxy chairman Tim Sukazi reveals the cost of Bernard Parker’s surgery
16:40 Cavin Johnson wants to get Amakhosi winning ‘playing the Kaizer Chiefs way’
16:39 SA’s first health information exchange CareConnect links patient records
16:34 LETTER: Bloody US war record