Celibate gay men welcome in priesthood, say senior church figures
Rev Prof Declan Marmion, dean of theology, Rev Prof Michael Mullaney, president Saint Patrick’s College, Maynooth and Fr Tomás Surlis pro-rector of Maynooth seminary. Photograph: Bryan O’Brien
Many Catholic weddings, funerals, and baptisms will be conducted in Ireland in the years ahead by lay men and women due to a lack of priests, senior figures at Ireland’s leading seminary have conceded.
Permission for the changes would have to be sought from the Vatican by Ireland’s bishops, Rev Prof Michael Mullaney, president at the Pontifical University, St Patrick’s College, Maynooth told The Irish Times.
“Many ecclesiastical offices are open to lay people – chancellor, parish administrators, [and] judges in tribunals; bishops can create ecclesiastical offices for the needs of their dioceses,” he said.
Certain things are reserved for priests, the celebration of the Eucharist and Confession “being the most obvious two”, said the rector at St Patrick’s College Rev Dr Tomás Surlis.
“But there is a whole range in which pastoral outreach takes place that are not necessarily reserved to ordained ministry. In Ireland we have not been good at embracing that reality,” he said.
Fr Mullaney, Fr Surlis and Maynooth’s other most senior figure, the dean of theology Rev Prof Declan Marmion, said gay men who live a celibate life are welcome in the priesthood.
Asked whether a gay man who believes he has a vocation and is capable of living a celibate life would be accepted, Fr Surlis responded, “I would say, yes. The same issue arises for a man who identifies as homosexual as arises for a man who identifies as heterosexual”.
Rev Marmion said: “I think we all know priests and bishops who are excellent ministers and make a great contribution to the church and society, who are gay but who are celibate. Being frank about it, I think that’s something we shouldn’t be afraid of saying.”
Fr Mullaney said Pope Francis does not have problem with gay priests. “Does he have a problem with deep-seated homosexual tendencies or people supporting and actively involved in gay culture? Yes.” But this view would also apply where heterosexuals were concerned, he insisted.