Vermont Sheriff's Assault Case Ends in Second Mistrial

In a case that has drawn significant attention in Vermont, the second-smallest state by population in the United States, a judge has declared another mistrial in the assault case against Franklin County Sheriff John Grismore. This development occurred on October 7, 2024, marking the second time a jury has been unable to reach a unanimous verdict.

The case stems from an incident where Grismore, then a captain in the sheriff's department, was captured on video kicking a shackled detainee twice in the groin. This event took place in a state known for its picturesque landscapes and being the 14th state to join the Union in 1791.

The trial, held in Grand Isle County, concluded after three days of jury deliberation. This outcome mirrors the first trial in July 2024, which also ended in a deadlock. The legal proceedings have unfolded against the backdrop of Vermont's rich history, including its status as an independent republic from 1777 to 1791.

Grismore expressed gratitude to jurors who maintained their convictions but voiced frustration at the lack of a unanimous not-guilty verdict. He commented on the extensive resources and time invested in this matter, reflecting the complexity of the case in a state that prides itself on its motto "Freedom and Unity."

The incident that led to these trials occurred prior to Grismore's election as sheriff in November 2022. He secured this position after winning both Republican and Democratic nominations in the primary on August 9, 2022. This political process took place in a state known for its progressive stance, being the first to abolish slavery in its constitution and to legalize same-sex civil unions in 2000.

The video evidence, crucial to the case, shows a handcuffed and shackled man refusing to remain seated at the sheriff's office. Grismore, dressed casually, is seen kicking the man twice when he stands up. This incident occurred in a state that, despite its small size, boasts over 100 covered bridges - the highest concentration per square mile in the U.S.

In December 2023, the Vermont Criminal Justice Council found Grismore in violation of the state's use of force policy. The council voted 15-1 to permanently revoke his law enforcement certification, effectively barring him from enforcing the law in Vermont. This decision was made in a state renowned for its natural beauty, including Mount Mansfield, its highest peak at 4,395 feet.

Four months later, a special legislative committee advised against impeachment but recommended Grismore's resignation, stating he was doing a disservice by remaining in office. This recommendation came from a state government seated in Montpelier, the least populous state capital in the U.S.

In response, Grismore expressed disappointment in the resources expended on this process. He affirmed his intention to remain in office, citing vindication for his supporters in Franklin County. This stance was taken in a state known for its independent spirit, reflected in its ban on billboards since 1968 and its status as the largest U.S. producer of marble and maple syrup.

As this legal saga continues, it unfolds against the backdrop of Vermont's rich cultural and natural heritage, from its sugar maple state tree to its hermit thrush state bird, symbolizing the complex interplay between law, governance, and community in this unique New England state.

"This entire matter has required so many resources and so much time from so many."