FNM vice-chairman sues party leaders

By LEANDRA ROLLE

Tribune Staff Reporter

lrolle@tribunemedia.net

FREE National Movement vice-chairman Richard Johnson has taken legal action against party leaders Michael Pintard and Dr Duane Sands after being banned from attending future council meetings, which he claimed violated the party’s constitution.

According to a writ of summons filed on November 28, Mr Johnson, represented by attorney Gregory Moss, is seeking some $500,000 in compensation for general or exemplary damages concerning the suspension which stems from allegations that he “acted contrary to the interests of the party, its platform, policies” etc.

FNM leader Mr Pintard and FNM chairman Dr Sands are named as the defendants in this action.

 The writ notes that Dr Sands, in a memorandum dated October 30, informed Mr Johnson that he was suspending his membership rights and reassigning his duties as vice chairman in a move that was claimed to have been supported by Mr Pintard.

 However, according to the writ, neither man had the authority to do so under the FNM’s constitution.

 “No charge was laid against the plaintiff before the purported general suspension was imposed against the plaintiff, nor was the plaintiff afforded any opportunity to be heard and to respond to any allegations against him which gave rise to the purported general suspension,” the writ added.

 “In alternative, the purported general suspension of the plaintiff was imposed by the second defendant without any meeting of the executive committee having been called to consider and authorise the issuance of the charge - together with the particulars of the allegation upon which the charge is based.

 “In any event, the second defendant had no authority to relieve the plaintiff of ‘any duties previously assigned to [him] as vice chairman’ nor to deprive the plaintiff of his ‘responsibility for any of the constituency associations’ as such duties of the plaintiff were assigned to him by the executive committee and, therefore, could only have been revoked by the executive committee.”

 The writ further contends that Mr Johnson, to this day, is not allowed to sit in on any meetings of the party’s executive committee or Central Council.

 The action taken against Mr Johnson came after several meetings were held last month to allow committee members to vote on the matter.

 “No vote of the executive committee meeting was taken to effect or ratify the purported general suspension or otherwise to suspend the plaintiff’s membership in the FNM or to suspend or otherwise reassign the plaintiff’s duties as vice chairman,” the writ continued.

 “In any event, at all material times the executive committee did not have any authority under the FNM’s constitution or otherwise to cause the purported general suspension to be imposed against the plaintiff.

 “Accordingly, the purported general suspension of the plaintiff by the second defendant and/or by the executive committee was and is ultra vires the constitution of the Free National Movement and is accordingly null and void and of no effect.”

 In one meeting, Mr Johnson claimed to have asked Dr Sands for a written statement on the allegations made against him, but said he received no response

 The writ said after the executive meeting was adjourned, another meeting was called, but this time with the Central Council, where a motion was held to suspend Mr Johnson from future meetings of the council.

 According to the writ, “no quorum of the Central Council was present at the purported meeting.”

 Court documents also allege that those who voted in favour of the suspensions had displayed bias against Mr Johnson.

 The writ then points to the FNM’s mandatory disciplinary procedure, suggesting that procedures were not followed when Mr Johnson was banned.

 “The plaintiff was at that date deprived of the enjoyment of his membership rights and privileges under the mandatory disciplinary procedure inclusive of, but not limited to, service upon of a statement of charge as to the manner in which he is alleged to have ‘acted contrary to the interests of the party, its platform, programmes, policies or principles the executive committee,’ service upon him of  particulars of allegation with respect thereto, the referral of the same to the tribunal for determination of the same, and the opportunity to appear and be heard before the tribunal with respect thereto and be represented before the tribunal by a member of the FNM.”

  As a result, the writ notes that Mr Johnson is seeking for his rights to be reinstated, $250,000 in damages for “loss of and unlawful interference” of his membership, another $250,000 for “mental distress” concerning the matter and interest on the aforesaid damages, among other things.

 When contacted by this newspaper yesterday, Dr Sands said he had no comment on the matter.


Football news:

<!DOCTYPE html>
Kane on Tuchel: A wonderful man, full of ideas. Thomas in person says what he thinks
Zarema about Kuziaev's 350,000 euros a year in Le Havre: Translate it into rubles - it's not that little. It is commendable that he left
Aleksandr Mostovoy on Wendel: Two months of walking around in the middle of nowhere and then coming back and dragging the team - that's top level
Sheffield United have bought Euro U21 champion Archer from Aston Villa for £18.5million
Alexander Medvedev on SKA: Without Gazprom, there would be no Zenit titles. There is a winning wave in the city. The next victory in the Gagarin Cup will be in the spring
Smolnikov ended his career at the age of 35. He became the Russian champion three times with Zenit

1:25 Prime Minister Davis’ Contribution to the Speech From The Throne Debate
0:29 Update 2 PMH Technical Outage
22:33 West Grand Bahama and Bimini welcome PM Davis and candidate Kingsley Smith as they arrive in Freeport…
22:33 West Grand Bahama and Bimini in the hundreds welcome PM Davis and candidate Kingsley Smith as they arrive in Freeport…
22:30 Bahamas Flying Ambassadors Continue Halloween Fly-In Series to Abaco
22:20 Youth Minister tells the young, “never settle for your last achievement”: be willing to aspire to something not yet achieved
22:17 ALICIA WALLACE: The country’s real power problem
22:11 John Watling Distillery, Ltd. Expands Reach to the United States
21:53 EDITORIAL: As FTX saga unfolds, we need to hear the full story
20:57 ‘Remediation work has begun’ at a BPL diesel spill in Nicholls Town, Andros
20:54 Bahamas Power and Light signs industrial agreement with the Bahamas Electrical Utility Managerial Union
19:39 Govt spending over $1m to modernise and revamp website
19:32 The FNM ‘is fine just the way we are right now’, says leader on party convention
16:00 Royal Caribbean’s PI club in DEPP construction go-ahead
16:00 Gas leak victim’s damages cut 77%
16:00 FTX Bahamas: ‘Major progress’ in Ray talks
15:34 Female Atlantis worker stabbed at work by fellow employee
13:23 Minnis accuses Gov’t of ‘causing’ EU blacklisting
13:12 Minnis contradicts Wynn on Goodman’s Bay easement
13:07 North Andros ‘to get power relief’ from BPL
3:12 Safaree Shocked By Amara La Negra’s Crude Text About Vonshae’s Child On LHH Miami
2:21 CI Gibson High Achievers Get Cash Gifts from Marathon MP
19:25 Three die from Nassau Village on motorbikes in one week!
16:47 Minister Sweeting visits schools in the Family Islands during Local Government Junior Council elections process
21:22 EDITORIAL The Concept of Democracy
21:17 Life and Legacy of Obie Wilchcombe Honoured — MP’s pay special tribute in HOA
19:55 Former St. Anne’s student Tony Scriven died in an Industrial Accident on Sweetings Cay this morning…
19:55 Former St. Anne’s student and WSc employee Tony Scriven died in an Industrial Accident on Sweetings Cay this morning
18:58 Department of Information Technology arrested in gun raid!
17:28 QUEEN’S COLLEGE HEADBOY Dario Anthony Rahming Jr collapsed and died this morning during a school practise…
2:41 Proprietor of Cedar Crest and Yager Ruby Braithwaite Murdoch Hill passes…
1:40 Obediah Hercules Wilchcombe
0:25 An educator from Eleuthera was charged after being accused of touching a young female student…
0:17 $30m capitalisation approved for Bahamas Development Bank
0:11 Events to be held across the nation for National Youth Month
0:05 Former attorney jailed for 18 months
0:03 Not guilty plea to murder, attempted murder charges
0:02 Man charged with indecent assault
23:51 Another bad accident tonight outside the Killarney Headquarters!!!
23:28 NASTY male charged with sexual intercourse with his two younger siblings ages 6 and 9 – WELL WHAT IS DIS?
22:13 Clubs & Societies: September 29, 2023
21:58 DIANE PHILLIPS: Creative solutions needed to address society’s inequities
21:51 ONE ELEUTHERA FOUNDATION – Planning needed to preserve our distinct Bahamian culture
20:54 RODNEY “EAGLE” ALVIN GREEN
20:49 Melvin Joseph Forbes
20:39 KENNETH “JAKEY BOY” WILLIAMS
20:24 EDITORIAL: By-election discussions reveals respect for Obie
20:10 SHERWIN “SHIRE” BRANVILLE BARTLETT
20:08 Campbell applauds draft cannabis bill, says input from farmers necessary
20:02 A Government In Mourning — Veteran Broadcaster and Political Giant Dies
19:58 Bahamian Delegation At 78th UN General Assembly
19:48 THE GOSPEL OF “NO” — Mitchell Rejects ‘No’ on Climate Change and Reparations
19:44 Ferguson Returns As BPSU President
19:43 Port Lucaya Marketplace struggling to attract guests despite cruise passenger numbers
19:39 Mitchell, CARICOM Heads plead for UN Resolution on Haiti
19:33 Tourism Arrivals Reach 6 Million Mark
19:32 EDITORIAL FOR WHOM THE BELL TOLLS
19:21 Ambassador Jones Remembers Colleague
19:17 Ratheno Octavis Strachan
19:11 Senators Remember Wilchcombe — Wilchcombe Once Held Senator Seat
19:03 Nurse Recruitment Underway Says PHA Managing Director
19:02 No Shortage of Meds, Just Delays Says PHA
19:00 Two Murders One Day Apart — Murder Count Up 3 Notches
18:50 Merrill Eloise Rolle
18:27 UN Fellows Meet President of the 78th Session of the United Nations General Assembly
18:19 Wynn agrees to ‘quashing’ first penthouse approvals
18:15 ‘Lucrative prospects’: ArawakX refutes $2.4m insolvency woes
18:13 Howard Timothy Martin
18:10 AG brands The Bahamas’ insolvency regime ‘a joke’
18:09 Hanna-Martin Denies Cuban Teachers Can’t Speak English
18:05 Thousands Attend British Colonial Job Fair
17:48 Frederick Nigel Bowe
15:34 Grammy winning icon Sting to kick off Bahamas Culinary & Arts Festival presented by Baha Mar
14:58 International Culture, Wine & Food Festival has got next
14:45 Murray comes through for the Smokies
14:35 Wesley Rolle Invitational gets underway today
13:21 FNM claims Saudi loan agreement signed contrary to law
13:10 ‘No politics in wake of Obie’s death’
12:56 Davis is acting minister of social services
12:47 Many farmers excited about the prospect of growing cannabis, Campbell says
12:46 Ferguson unofficial winner of BPSU votes
12:39 Caribbean ‘must be united’ in climate change fight
12:37 In Grenada, PM calls for action on climate change fight
12:31 Bain apologises for Daxon’s message shared about Obie Wilchcombe
12:27 Man accused of molesting his sisters
12:24 INGRAHAM TO FNM: Sit out by-election . . . but party will run after decision by council members
12:18 Court upholds convictions, sentence of Abaco businessman on drugs, firearms charges
12:08 Improving food security 
12:02 A trinity returning home: Richie Adderley, Nathalee Martinborough, Obie Wilchcombe
11:54 The measure of a man 
4:38 Man shot dead in First Street and Poinciana The Grove Tuesday evening…
3:58 Bahamas Harvest Church Hosts Nurses Recognition Luncheon 
3:35 PM DAVIS: “We cannot leave COP28 without Pledges for Loss & Damage”
21:40 U.S. Embassy Selects USG Alumna Lakeisha Rolle to Receive $20,000 to Empower Young Entrepreneurs
20:24 BAHAMAS AND KINGDOM OF SAUDI ARABIA EXECUTE LOAN AGREEMENT FOR FAMILY ISLAND AIRPORT DEVELOPMENT
20:08 STATESIDE: While Biden tries to appear as ‘labour’s best friend’ Trump seems to lose favour
20:00 FRONT PORCH: The neglect and needs of Caribbean and Pacific states
19:17 PHA confirms 145 infections of dengue fever with six hospitalised
19:13 Dr Rolle: PHA dealing with shortage of cancer medicine and nurses
18:13 ‘BISX home makes sense’ for Bahamas carbon credits