Federal court rules that House committee can access Trump’s tax records

U.S. President Donald Trump [January 25, 2019. REUTERS/Kevin Lamarque]

A federal appeals court unanimously ruled Tuesday that a House committee can access former President Donald Trump’s tax records following a yearslong legal battle.

A three-judge panel of the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals agreed that the House Ways and Means Committee has the authority to obtain Trump’s tax records from the Treasury Department, upholding a district court ruling from late last year.

Trump’s lawyers are all but certain to appeal the ruling. NBC News has reached out to a Trump spokesman and a member of his legal team for comment.

Former US President Donald Trump [File: Jonathan Ernst/Reuters]
The court ruling adds to Trump’s legal woes following an FBI search of his Mar-a-Lago home on Monday. A source familiar with the matter told NBC News that the search was tied to classified information Trump allegedly took with him from the White House to his Palm Beach resort in January 2021.

Tuesday’s appeals court ruling is the latest twist in a multi-year legal fight over his tax records. A federal judge in December tossed out Trump’s lawsuit seeking to block the House panel from obtaining his tax returns, rejecting the former president’s claim that Congress had no legitimate need to look at the returns and that Congress was simply snooping around in an effort to embarrass him.

House Ways and Means Committee Chairman Richard Neal, D-Mass., on Tuesday lauded the appeals court’s “long-anticipated” opinion. Neal first requested copies of Trump’s federal tax returns in April 2019, a request the Treasury Department initially refused.

“With great patience, we followed the judicial process, and yet again, our position has been affirmed by the Courts,” Neal said in a statement. “When we receive the returns, we will begin our oversight of the IRS’s mandatory presidential audit program.”

Neal had initially cited a federal law that requires the Treasury Department and the IRS to turn over individual tax returns when demanded by any of the three congressional tax committees.

“The Chairman has identified a legitimate legislative purpose that it requires information to accomplish,” the appeals court ruling states. “At this stage, it is not our place to delve deeper than this. The mere fact that individual members of Congress may have political motivations as well as legislative ones is of no moment. Indeed, it is likely rare that an individual member of Congress would work for a legislative purpose without considering the political implications.”

The ruling means Trump would have to ask the full circuit court to rehear the case or appeal directly to the Supreme Court. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., called the court’s decision a “victory for the rule of law,” in a statement Tuesday.

“Access to the former president’s tax returns is crucial to upholding the public interest, our national security & our Democracy,” Pelosi said. (NBC NEWS)


Football news:

<!DOCTYPE html>
Kane on Tuchel: A wonderful man, full of ideas. Thomas in person says what he thinks
Zarema about Kuziaev's 350,000 euros a year in Le Havre: Translate it into rubles - it's not that little. It is commendable that he left
Aleksandr Mostovoy on Wendel: Two months of walking around in the middle of nowhere and then coming back and dragging the team - that's top level
Sheffield United have bought Euro U21 champion Archer from Aston Villa for £18.5million
Alexander Medvedev on SKA: Without Gazprom, there would be no Zenit titles. There is a winning wave in the city. The next victory in the Gagarin Cup will be in the spring
Smolnikov ended his career at the age of 35. He became the Russian champion three times with Zenit

23:57 VENEZUELA-GUYANA-BORDER: Bipartisan foreign relations committee agrees to table parliamentary motion, ramp up public awareness
23:30 First Lady sponsors mammograms for 222 women
21:58 Mon Repos fire was maliciously set – GFS
21:25 Fire destroys Mon Repos house
20:57 Vybz Kartel Scolds His Sons Likkle Vybz & Addi For Mocking Cashier
20:57 21 Savage Link Up With Popcaan In Jamaica His Second Trip Outside US
20:36 Murder Update: 3 other suspects deny involvement in crime
19:54 Scavenger Hunt & Cook Out events planned for Int’l Men’s Day celebrations
19:16 CARICOM says Venezuela’s referendum has no bearing on international law
19:10 Deadly fire update: Mother was cooking dinner when lit kerosene stove fell
18:43 Venezuela’s proposed referendum on Guyana’s Essequibo region has no validity in int’l law – CARICOM 
17:40 GMSA lauds Pres. Ali, Norton unified commitment to fight Venezuela’s attempts to undermine Guyana’s development
17:12 Cop to be charged for reversing pickup into pedestrian
16:15 Baby dies in Linden fire
16:08 Murder update: Suspect & victim were ‘close friends’ – source
15:17 Unified front critical for ensuring maintenance of Guyana’s territorial integrity – GCCI
15:07 Current pace of works on Linden-Mabura road not satisfactory – PS
15:03 Bartica mason charged for “Causing a Child to Watch a Sexual Act”
14:31 Pink River Dolphins observed in Rupununi; research conducted
14:24 Giving Hope Foundation honours cancer patients, survivors at annual gala
13:36 Murder update: $7.7M in cash found at suspect’s house
10:59 OPINION: A response to Dr Randolph Persaud
10:53 OPINION: The death of responsible journalism
10:20 Fire leaves three homeless
10:05 Venezuela border controversy: No effort to be spared in resisting Venezuela’s intimidation tactics – Govt, Opposition
10:04 Largest batch of 3500 students set to graduate from UG next month
10:03 Venezuelan man caught in Guyana with guns, drugs jailed
9:35 ‘We are all completely united’
9:30 US$40M wastewater treatment plant on the cards for Georgetown
7:09 Man lured to house, murdered; suspect confesses
4:59 Hess, Chevron shareholders question stability of Stabroek Block deal as Guyanese ramp-up call for renegotiation
4:58 BREAKING NEWS: Man confesses to murdering businessman’s son after luring him to buy gold
4:57 ExxonM billed Guyana US$753M for foreign workers here and abroad
2:30 New Demerara River Bridge is 27% complete – Edghill
2:01 GGDMA supports Govt’s move to eradicate unlawful gold trade in Guyana
10:30 Gov’t to implement electricity tax for large companies on GPL grid as consumption peaks – VP Jagdeo
10:25 Over 200 units of blood donated
10:20 Over 50,000 persons gained employment since 2020
10:05 Cyberbullying…The Upstanders
10:05 Large-scale GPL consumers asked to leave grid during peak hours or pay increased rates – Pres Ali
10:04 Guyana living with effects of APNU/AFC botching energy sector – Jagdeo on blackouts
10:03 Guyana, UAE discuss climate security, agri, infrastructure development
10:02 Police ordered to seize boats carrying influx of Venezuelan migrants in Region 3
10:00 Rotary Club collects 67 units of blood during State House drive
9:55 Mixed …messages to Big Brother
9:45 A song for you to help save humanity
9:35 That Opposition Washington trip
9:30 Changes being made to address concerns at ‘West Dem’ Hospital
9:25 NDMA leads the way in Cybersecurity education
9:20 ANTIBIOTICS: FOODS TO EAT & FOODS TO AVOID
9:20 CARE FOR THE ELDERLY DOG (continued)
9:20 Chinese Modernization…
9:15 True development can come to any country only when there is peace
9:15 No place for the lazy, backwards, bigoted, race-baiting politics of PNC/APNU/AFC
9:10 No place for lazy, backward, bigoted, race-baiting PNC/APNU/AFC politics
9:05 Unpatriotic and Misleading
9:05 President Ali is a formidable leader
8:55 Sweet pepper jelly anyone?
8:25 SBM, VMFA team up for Women’s Football training project
8:20 REFLECTIONS OF A COUNTRY GIRL AND THE DREAM THAT FOUND HER
8:20 National Senior Track and Field Championships: Smith, Holder bag 100M Gold
8:15 GCB Senior Intercounty Super50 tourney: Sinclair shines in low- scoring thriller on opening day
8:10 World Classic & Equipped Masters Powerlifting Championships 2023: Taharally, Rogers to represent Guyana
8:05 Developments in local football: GFF, USA’s Blackpool establish player-scouting network
8:00 GFF boss Forde conducts outreach to Bartica
7:33 Modern ways needed for increased production – Agri Minister
7:32 Govt will continue developing programmes to uplift lives of Amerindians – PM
7:28 Mahdia man beaten, stabbed to death by brothers
7:25 Grove man admits theft, jailed for 6 months
7:24 Personalised learning, internet needed to improve education in hinterland – Wapichan youth 
7:03 Investigation completed on 5-year-old child’s death
6:35 Dehring bemoans Jamaica missing out on global showpiece
6:30 GFF signs groundbreaking MOU with BSCNA
6:25 County Championship: Hampshire take last four Surrey wickets to beat champions
6:15 Deitz looking for Windies to step up against Aussies
6:05 Wolves shock Manchester City to end perfect League start
4:59 Government removes August oil production data from website with no explanation
4:58 Pregnant Venezuelan identifies doctor as rapist
4:57 Erica Mena Questions Mona Scott-Young’s Olivia Pope Post After Firing
4:57 Loophole in Stabroek Block deal gives Exxon power to revise gas terms for more benefits
4:52 Govt. makes 5th withdrawal from NRF
4:51 Rum thief jailed for six months
4:50 H@rd Truths by GHK Lall – Development in the midst of differences
4:39 ‘Beyond the Brush’ charms local art lovers at inaugural exhibition
4:39 GFF President records positive outreach in Bartica
4:38 US$5M West Central Mall opens in Region Three
4:04 True development can only come to any country when there is peace
4:03 Is there Compensation Management in the Public Service?
4:02 The Opposition in Washington on discrimination charges
1:54 Boat load of Venezuelan migrants lands on East Bank Essequibo seashore
0:13 Govt asking big power users to leave grid during peak hours or pay increase rates
18:34 Electrical sparks caused by power surge was source of Eccles fire – GFS
17:34 Farfan & Mendes empowering industry solutions with Belzona partnership
17:12 Healthcare services improving as govt confront certain chronic problems – MOH
12:18 City Hall building roof expected to be completed within two months
12:14 Six bridges completed on Kurupukari to Lethem route
12:07 Investors “overwhelmingly confident” in Guyana, PPP/C Govt – Jagdeo as new West Central Mall opens
12:06 Article 13 and the nature of Homo sapiens in Guyana
10:23 Big electricity consumers to be taxed off GPL’s grid as hot weather spikes electricity consumption
10:05 Govt withdraws another $10.4B from Natural Resource Fund