In the realm of contemporary horror cinema, James Watkins' "Speak No Evil" emerges as a provocative and unsettling experience. This remake of Christian Tafdrup's 2022 Danish film of the same name offers a fresh perspective on social discomfort and the consequences of remaining silent in the face of escalating tension.
The narrative centers around the Dalton family - Louise (Mackenzie Davis), Ben (Scoot McNairy), and their 11-year-old daughter Agnes (Alix West Lefler). Recently relocated to London, this seemingly ordinary American family finds themselves entangled in a nightmarish scenario when they accept an invitation to visit the countryside estate of their new acquaintances, Paddy (James McAvoy) and Ciara (Aisling Franciosi).
Watkins' adaptation skillfully builds tension, starting with a "civilized simmer" that gradually intensifies. The film explores themes of social etiquette, manipulation, and the inability to speak up against perceived wrongs. This clever "comedy of manners" evolves into a Grand Guignol-esque spectacle, a theatrical style known for its naturalistic horror shows in late 19th and early 20th century Paris.
The movie's technical aspects contribute significantly to its impact. The tightly constructed script is complemented by witty editing, playful camera work, and an unsettling score. The sound design, a crucial element in horror films since the early days of cinema, plays a pivotal role in creating an atmosphere of dread.
James McAvoy's performance stands out, with the Scottish actor, known for his versatility since his breakthrough in the early 2000s, delivering a brawny and charismatic portrayal of the enigmatic host. His character often serves as a counterpoint to Davis's uptight Louise, challenging the audience's sympathies.
The film cleverly incorporates modern concerns, such as sustainable fishing practices, which became a global issue in recent decades. It also plays with horror movie tropes, like the classic "don't go in the basement" scenario that has been a staple of the genre since the early 20th century.
Interestingly, the movie features a sound design gag involving a Vespa, the iconic Italian scooter first produced in 1946. This detail, along with the use of the Bangles' 1988 hit "Eternal Flame," adds layers of cultural references to the film's texture.
Watkins' remake encourages audience participation, a practice that became popular in horror screenings during the 1970s and 1980s. Viewers may find themselves compelled to shout advice at the screen, reminiscent of interactive horror experiences.
"It's a smart film about dumb decisions, and it's possible to enjoy sneering at McNairy's utterly drippy sad dad while shoving down all those pesky inner thoughts about the times we've bitten our own tongues around a blowhard, or pledged to do lunch with our fingers crossed."
In conclusion, "Speak No Evil" offers a potent blend of horror and social commentary. It challenges viewers to confront their own tendencies to remain silent in uncomfortable situations, all while delivering a visceral and unsettling cinematic experience. With its R rating, introduced by the MPAA in 1968, the film promises intense content for mature audiences, pushing the boundaries of the horror genre in thought-provoking ways.