Churches Launch Christian Schools Amid Growing School Choice Debate

In recent years, a notable trend has emerged across the United States: churches are increasingly establishing new Christian schools on their premises. This development comes as part of a broader movement to provide parents with educational options that align more closely with religious values.

The rise of these church-affiliated schools is not primarily driven by state school voucher programs. However, these programs are facilitating the start-up process by making taxpayer funding more readily available for K-12 private school tuition in states like Florida and Ohio. Troy McIntosh, executive director of the Ohio Christian Education Network, emphasizes the desire for widespread access to Christian education, stating, "We didn't need five Christian schools in the state — we needed 50."

This trend gained momentum following pandemic-era scrutiny of public school curricula, particularly regarding topics such as gender and sexuality. In Christian classrooms, religious beliefs can inform character-building lessons, and teachers have the freedom to incorporate biblical teachings across various subjects.

The movement towards church-sponsored schools is part of a larger national debate on school choice. In 2023, Ohio implemented universal school choice, allowing taxpayer dollars to fund private school tuition without income restrictions. This policy shift reflects a broader wave of school voucher laws passed nationwide, including in Arizona, Florida, and West Virginia.

"We're not trying to burn anything down. We're trying to build something constructive."

Advocates argue that these initiatives aim to provide parents with more options rather than undermine public schools. However, opponents express concerns about potential church-state separation issues and the impact on public school funding.

Rachel Laser, president of Americans United for Separation of Church and State, argues that taxpayer funding for private schools violates religious freedom. Similarly, Melissa Erickson, director of Alliance for Public Schools in Florida, worries about the lack of accountability in these new educational ventures.

The debate surrounding school choice has deep historical roots. The concept of school vouchers was first proposed by economist Milton Friedman in 1955, with the first modern program implemented in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, in 1990. As of 2024, approximately 30 states have some form of school choice program.

Statistics reveal that conservative Christian schools accounted for nearly 12% of private school options in the 2021-22 academic year. Enrollment in these schools has grown significantly, with a 15% increase in 2021 compared to 2019. The Association of Christian Schools International, representing about 2,200 U.S. schools, reported 17 churches in its emerging schools program in the summer of 2024.

This trend occurs against the backdrop of a complex educational landscape in the United States. While about 10% of all U.S. students attend private schools, the average cost of private school tuition is around $12,000 per year. In contrast, the U.S. spends approximately $14,000 per student annually on public education.

As the debate continues, it's clear that the intersection of education, religion, and public policy will remain a contentious issue in American society for the foreseeable future.