History experts explain what Trump's comeback means for America's future

Two top historians analyze Trumpʼs return to power through historical lens comparing it with past political shifts. Their insights show how US political system changed over time

November 8 2024 , 06:23 PM  •  602 views

History experts explain what Trump's comeback means for America's future

In a ground-breaking political shift Donald Trump secured another presidential term making him the first non-consecutive winner since the 19th century. His win (that might include popular vote too) marks a major change in US political landscape

The historical weight of this moment brings up serious questions about American democracyʼs path. Julian Zelizer from Princeton sees Bidenʼs term as possible one-time break in a larger trend: “I didnt think of Trumps first term as a blip; it came from deeper changes in Republican and American politics“

The greatest threat to any republic was a demagogue

Joanne Freeman explains Founding Fathersʼ view

Looking at executive power its clear how much things changed. While the Constitution created checks-and-balances system modern presidents got way more authority than planned. After 9-11 presidential power grew even bigger; now Trump plans to use it fully

The election shows deep divide in American society - similar to late-60s tensions. Economic changes worked well for some groups but left others behind which created long-lasting distrust in institutions. Zelizer points out: todays voters care more about burger prices than warnings about democracy

Political violence isnt new in US history. From 1850s Congress fights to modern threats theres always been conflict during big changes. Now with rigid voting maps and close margins between parties every small shift can change power balance. As Freeman notes: “American political history is violent; its not an exception“

We were improvising; we made mistakes

John Adams on founding era