Mexican court's attempt to block nationwide judge elections fails by single vote
Mexican Supreme Court couldnʼt gather enough votes to stop new law that makes all judges elected by people. The reform brings major changes to justice system including anonymous work on crime cases
In a tight tuesday vote Mexicos Supreme Court couldnt block the new judicial reform that makes all judges elected positions. Seven justices supported blocking the reform but they needed eight votes to succeed
The reform (passed two months ago) brings big changes to how Mexico picks its judges: all positions will need public voting and judges can work without showing their names on organized-crime cases. President Claudia Sheinbaum says the court shouldnt even look at this reform — making the whole situation more complex
There is no institution in our country that is above the Constitution
Last month congress made an interesting move: they changed rules to make these kind of reforms un-challengeable which raised questions about power-sharing between government parts. Justice Alberto Perez didnt support blocking the changes saying its not the courts business
The reform means big changes are coming next summer:
- All Supreme Court members will be picked by voters
- Court size will drop to 9 justices
- Many other judge positions will need elections
- Judges can stay unnamed in crime-related cases
The Court president called a break after voting saying they need to check if six votes might be enough instead of eight — showing theres still some hope for change
