South Africa

LETTER: The JSC may advise the president to suspend John Hlophe

The response of the Judicial Service Commission (JSC) to the call for the suspension of Western Cape judge president John Hlophe is encapsulated in a report in Legalbrief on Wednesday morning:

JSC spokesperson CP Fourie said the effect of these as-yet unresolved processes was that the JSC was unable to make any recommendations to President Cyril Ramaphosa that Hlophe be removed or suspended from his position: “... the JSC is currently not in a position to do anything in response to the call for the judge president's suspension.”

Fourie is quite wrong regarding the legal position. He should acquaint himself with the provisions of section 177 of the constitution and also understand that a precautionary suspension (aka “gardening leave”) is not designed to punish the alleged miscreant, but to protect the reputation of the institution that takes the step of suspending any person who is under a cloud of suspicion of wrongdoing.

The removal from office of a judge is another, far more serious, matter and different consideration apply. However, the law makes it clear that while the JSC ponders whether a judge is guilty of gross misconduct, it is empowered to advise the president to suspend the judge in question.

Until there is legal finality on the complaint of the justices of the Constitutional Court against Hlophe (which could take years if Hlophe runs true to form by persisting in his Stalingrad strategy) the JSC is at large to advise the president to suspend him. Hlophe has been on suspension in the past and should be suspended again now, before more damage in done.

Paul Hoffman, SC
Accountability Now

JOIN THE DISCUSSION: Send us an e-mail with your comments. Letters of more than 300 words will be edited for length. Send your letter by e-mail to letters@businesslive.co.za. Anonymous correspondence will not be published. Writers should include a daytime telephone number.

Football news:

Contrast before the whistle in Prague: Slavia players lined up in front of a kneeling Arsenal
Unai Emery: I am used to matches against my former clubs, so the games with Arsenal are not something new
I drink beer, champagne, red wine. I eat cheese and caviar. Figo about watching football
Figo about Messi and Ronaldo: Truffles with caviar is difficult to compare
Pogba on the substitution at half-time: They tried to provoke me for the 2nd yellow card. The coach decided that it would be better if I left the field before the red
Ole Gunnar Solskjaer: Manchester United are in for a real European battle with Roma. We are good against the Italians
Mikel Arteta: An important victory at a crucial moment, but it will be difficult for Arsenal. Emery is the most successful coach in the history of the Europa League