Praveen Halappanavar, who did not respond to the request for comment, told the Guardian newspaperin 2013that an investigation into the death of his wife "proved" his version of the event. Told. "The doctor told him he couldn't have an abortion because it's a Catholic country," he told the question.
After the report was published, University Hospital Galway apologized to Harapanavar's family in a statement stating that "there was a failure in the standards of care provided".
"We can reassure everyone who is concerned that they have already implemented the changes to avoid repeating such events," he added.
Threat to mother's life
In some American states, "Trigger Act" prohibits abortion Enacted —Provides some exceptions, such as in the case of rape and incest, and currently allows abortion if the mother's life is at serious risk. Much — manyexperts are wondering how easy it is to get such an exception. In addition, asking doctors to interpret complex laws during a medical emergency can lead to dangerous decisions, they said.
2012 Irish law allowed abortion to prevent "potentially significant danger or threat to the mother's life." However, according to Harapanavar's report, doctors have determined that the abortion has not reached the point "allowed by Irish law."
This is not a theoretical scenario in the United States, says Dr. Jen Gunter, California-based OB-GYN and author of The Vagina Bible.
"I personally had a situation where miscarriage in a medical center was illegal by state law and some patients needed it," she said in an interview. Refused to share. The details of the case, except for the fact that it was Kansas, , with some restrictions, abortion is legal for up to 22 weeks.
"It wasn't a complication of pregnancy, her organs weren't functioning because of the extra burden of pregnancy because of her underlying condition," she added. rice field.
A lawyer at the Kansas Medical Center told Gunter that she couldn't perform an abortion unless she was exposed to "imminent danger."
"I was like,'What does that mean?' And their interpretation was that she would die in the next three minutes, "she said. According to Gunter, a hospital lawyer called a state politician involved in the law and said, "Doctor, do what you think is best."
"So I wondered,'Why do we have this law?'" She said.
Ectopic pregnancy — fertilized eggs can be transplanted outside the womb, often into the Faropius canal and grow, endangering the life of the mother — further confusion Caused a new law, she said.
Gunter spares no hesitation in her predictions of what the stricter abortion law in the United States means.
Despite better antibiotics to treat septic abortion, she said women could die
"Harapanabar. It happened here. When it will never change the situation in the United States, and it will happen. "
Ivana Bacik, the leader of the Irish Labor Party and a long-time advocate of abortion rights, said Monday. Protested the Supreme Court's decision outside the US Embassy in Dublin. ..
"In our experience here, banning abortion and considering it a crime puts the life of a woman at risk. It is now a terrifying reality for American women. It's very obvious, "she said.
"Removing the right to abortion from women and girls puts them at risk of life. In reality, life-threatening and health-threatening conditions occur during pregnancy. "Well."
Bacik said Halappanavar's story helped change public opinion for the 2018 "yes" vote. She was 18 weeks pregnant, so after a lengthy court battle, she was turned off only more than three weeks after she was declared clinically dead in 2014.
In March, a charity of 20 women's rights and health carecommissioned a pollon the island in a government review of the ongoing abortion law in Ireland. 67% of all people are aborted — reflecting support for the 2018 “yes” vote.
Still, opponents of abortion rights in Ireland continue to fight. The Right to Life rally will be held in Dublin on Saturday. There, the organizers "call on sympathizers to say that 6,500 babies are killed in miscarriage each year."
Composition of the Laos Offery in Midland, Ireland Carol Nolan, an independent legislator on behalf of the members, opposed the 2018 revision of the law, arguing that the death of Harapanabar had been misrepresented "intentionally and continuously" by female rights activists. increase.
"At that time, the overwhelming contributors to Sabita's death were medical negligence and mismanagement of maternal septicemia," she said in an email, pre-2018 law (8th Amendment). Known as) is not a barrier to Halappanavar receiving proportional and effective care.
"After the abolition of constitutional amendments, the number of abortions has skyrocketed and political and non-governmental pressures have been constantly applied to further expand the parameters of the law since 2018. "Nolan said.
According to the latest figures available from the national government, there were 32 abortions in Ireland in 2018, and more than 6,000 each in the following two years.
"This was completely predictable," Nolan added. "But it only helped to establish my own view that the 8th Amendment acted as a beacon of proportionality and sound law based on the true vision of human rights."
In the discussion, the sometimes deadly crossroads of law and medicine were also fascinated by those who supported the right to abortion.
Dublin legislator Bacik quoted the case of Andrea Prudente. This denied a miscarriage after an American woman who washad a major bleeding in Malta on June 12she was airlifted to Spain, where she was treated, Her fetus was removed.
Multiple cases of women who died after being denied abortionemerged from Poland, with an almost complete ban on abortion. Last year, a 30-year-old woman, known only as Isabella, who was 22 weeks pregnant, died of septic shock.Her family said thescan showed multiple problems with the fetus, but the doctor refused to end there. It was a fetal heartbeat, Reuters reported.
After the death of the fetal, doctors can legally perform surgery. However, Isabella's heart stopped on her way to the operating room, creating a cesaria section.
In a subsequentmass protestin Poland, she was flagged with the slogan "Her heart was also beating."
